STONE
DISEASE
Efficacy
of tamsulosin in the medical management of juxtavesical ureteral stones
Dellabella M, Milanese G, Muzzonigro G
Department of Urology, A. O. Umberto I-Torrette, University of Ancona,
Italy
J Urol. 2003; 170: 2202-5
-
Purpose:
We evaluated the efficacy of the alpha1-adrenergic antagonist tamsulosin
for conservative expulsive therapy in patients with ureteral colic due
to juxtavesical stones.
-
Materials and Methods:
A total of 60 consecutive symptomatic patients with stones located in
the juxtavesical tract of the ureter were randomly divided into group
1-30 who received oral floroglucine-trimetossibenzene 3 times daily
and group 2-30 who received 0.4 mg tamsulosin daily. The 2 groups received
30 mg deflazacort daily for 10 days plus cotrimoxazole 2 times daily
for 8 days and 75 mg diclofenac injected intramuscularly on demand.
Ultrasound followup and medical visits were performed weekly for 4 weeks.
Stone passage rate and time, analgesic use, hospitalization and endoscopical
intervention were evaluated. Statistical analysis was performed using
the Student t test.
-
Results: The
stone expulsion rate was 70% for group 1 and 100% for group 2. Mean
stone size was 5.8 and 6.7 mm, respectively (p = 0.001). Mean expulsion
time was 111.1 hours for group 1 and 65.7 hours for group 2 (p = 0.020).
The mean number of diclofenac injections was 2.83 for group 1 and 0.13
for group 2 (p < 0.0001). Ten group 1 patients were hospitalized,
of whom 9 underwent ureteroscopy, compared with none in group 2 (p <
0.0001 and 0.001, respectively).
-
Conclusions:
Tamsulosin used as a spasmolytic drug during renal colic due to juxtavesical
calculi increased the stone expulsion rate and decreased expulsion time,
the need for hospitalization and endoscopic procedures, and provided
particularly good control of colic pain.
- Editorial
Comment
The likelihood of spontaneous passage of stones in the ureter depends
primarily on the size and location of the stone at the time of diagnosis.
Although most ureteral stones pass spontaneously, the pain and cost
associated with repeated episodes of renal colic is substantial. A number
of investigators have evaluated the use of pharmacologic agents to enhance
the rate and reduce the pain of spontaneous passage of ureteral calculi
and demonstrated a beneficial effect of some medications (references
4 and 6 in the article). The efficacy of corticosteroids and calcium
channel blockers has been attributed to their ability to reduce ureteral
edema and spasm.
In the current study, Dellabella and colleagues theorized that the use
of an alpha-adrenergic antagonist would reduce ureteral peristalsis
around an obstructing ureteral stone, thereby increasing urine flow
and improving the likelihood of spontaneous passage. In a prospective,
randomized trial, these investigators compared tamsulosin with an anti-spasmotic
agent (floroglucine-trimetossibenzene) in 60 patients with stones in
the intramural ureter. After 4 weeks, all patients in the tamsulosin
group successfully passed their stones compared with only 70% in the
anti-spasmotic group. Furthermore, patients in the tamsulosin group
passed their stones in less time (66 hours vs. 111 hours, respectively)
and required less pain medication (0.13 vs. 2.83 injections diclofenac,
respectively) than the anti-spasmotic group.
These findings again suggest that pharmacotherapy aimed at decreasing
ureteral peristalsis associated with an obstructing stone can reduce
pain and enhance spontaneous stone passage. Although few adverse effects
from drug therapy have been reported in the current and previous trials,
one must still weigh the risks of pharmocotherapy against the benefit
of spontaneous stone passage for each patient. The efficacy of alpha-blocker
therapy for the management of ureteral stones will need to be confirmed
in future trials; however, the use of adjunctive drug therapy in patients
electing to manage their ureteral stones conservatively should be considered.
Dr.
Margaret S. Pearle
Associate Professor of Urology
University of Texas Southwestern Med Ctr
Dallas, Texas, USA
Urinary stone size: comparison of abdominal plain radiography
and noncontrast CT measurements
Parsons JK, Lancini V, Shetye K, Regan F, Potter SR, Jarrett TW
James Buchanan Brady Urological Institute, The Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions,
Baltimore, Maryland 21287-2101, USA
J. Endourol. 2003; 17: 725-8
- Background
and Purpose: To compare urinary stone size as measured by abdominal
plain radiography (AXR) with stone size as measured by noncontrast three-dimensional
spiral CT in patients with acute renal colic.
-
Patients and Methods:
Patients presenting to the emergency room of a single institution with
urinary stones that were visible on both AXR and noncontrast spiral
CT were identified. Two radiologists blinded to the clinical outcomes
separately and randomly reviewed all films and measured maximum longitudinal
(craniocaudal) and transverse (anteroposterior) stone diameters. The
two-tailed paired Student’s t-test was used to compare the sizes
of each stone on AXR and CT.
-
Results:
Over a 1-year period, 22 patients were identified with a total of 31
urinary stones visible on both AXR and CT. Nineteen stones were located
in the kidney, three in the midureter, and nine in the distal ureter.
The mean stone size by AXR was 6.1 mm (range 2-13 mm; SD +/- 1.95) in
the longitudinal axis and 5.3 mm (range 2-11 mm; SD +/- 1.50) in the
transverse axis. The mean stone size by CT was 6.9 mm (range 3-12 mm;
SD +/- 1.95) in the longitudinal axis and 6.1 mm (range 2-11 mm; SD
+/- 1.50) in the transverse. The differences between AXR and CT measurements
did not attain significance in either the longitudinal (p = 0.67) or
the transverse (p = 0.25) axis.
-
Conclusions:
A CT scan provides estimates of stone size that are consistently greater
than those of AXR in both the longitudinal and transverse axes. However,
for stones between 2 and 13 mm in maximum diameter, these differences
do not attain significance. In patients with a history of radiopaque
stones in this size range, therefore, AXR may provide useful size data
for clinical decision-making without concern about significant disparities
between the two modalities. As AXRs are more expeditiously obtained,
incur less direct costs, and expose patients to significantly lower
doses of radiation than CT scans, they remain a useful adjunctive study
in the work-up of nephrolithiasis.
- Editorial
Comment
It is clear that CT is the most sensitive imaging modality for the detection
of renal and ureteral calculi. However, the accuracy of CT compared
with abdominal radiography for the measurement of stone size has been
debated. A previous report suggested that CT overestimated the craniocaudad
dimension of ureteral stones by a mean of 0.8 mm. In contrast the current
report by Parsons and colleagues found concurrence between CT and abdominal
x-ray (AXR) for both the transverse and longitudinal dimensions, although
the measurements were consistently longer (but not statistically significantly
so) by CT. Speculation that CT overestimates the longitudinal dimension
as a result of volume averaging failed to hold true in this prospective
comparison.
Although follow-up imaging after CT diagnosis of stones is best done
with AXR from a cost-effective and radiation exposure standpoint, this
study suggests that the CT estimate of stone size may reliably be used
to make treatment decisions regarding renal and ureteral stones. Conversely,
using CT as the gold standard for stone measurement as suggested by
in vitro studies (reference 6 and 7 in the article), AXR provides a
comparable measure of stone size and may likewise be used for treatment
decision-making.
Dr.
Margaret S. Pearle
Associate Professor of Urology
University of Texas Southwestern Med Ctr
Dallas, Texas, USA
ENDOUROLOGY
& LAPAROSCOPY
Predictive
factors for applicability and success with endoscopic treatment of upper
tract urothelial carcinoma
Suh RS, Faerber GJ, Wolf Jr. JS
From the Department of Urology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan
J Urol. 2003; 170: 2209-16
-
Purpose:
We report on endoscopic treatment outcomes for upper tract urothelial
carcinoma and identify predictive factors for success.
- Materials
and Methods: A total of 61 renal units were referred for endoscopic
treatment of an upper tract tumor, 69% of which did not have a traditional
indication for nephron sparing approaches. Tumor pathology and operative
findings were assessed retrospectively for treatment outcomes and influential
factors.
-
Results:
Initial ureteroscopic inspection was undertaken in 53 renal units with
resection attempted in 18 (34%) resulting in an 89% success rate with
16 treated. A percutaneous approach in 19 renal units (11 after ureteroscopy)
was 100% successful in achieving tumor-free status, for a total of 35
renal units successfully treated endoscopically. Surveillance then began
on 27 renal units with a recurrence rate of 88% and mean time to recurrence
of 5.8 months (range 2 to 20). Of patients undergoing surveillance (31%
of whom had high grade disease), 54% remain or have died of unrelated
disease, during a mean followup of 21.0 months (range 3 to 48). Higher
tumor grade, larger size, renal pelvis location (all p < 0.01) and
multifocality (p = 0.05) significantly correlated with decreased recurrence-free
survival, but did not predict failure of local control by endoscopic
surveillance.
-
Conclusions:
Although endoscopic techniques can render most patients tumor-free,
there is a high associated recurrence rate and many need repeat procedures.
Recurrence-free survival is greater in patients with low grade, solitary
or less bulky disease. However, rigorous surveillance after endoscopic
resection can lead to success even in patients with high grade, multifocal
or large volume disease, resulting in preservation of renal units.
- Editorial
Comment
Among a heterogeneous population of patients with upper tract urothelial
carcinoma, two-thirds of whom did not have a traditional indication
for renal preservation; tumor size was the most important factor in
deciding whether or not to attempt endoscopic resection. Although disease
recurrence is increased with higher grade, larger, multifocal or renal
pelvic location, once the tumor is resected these factors do not significantly
influence whether or not recurrences can be successfully managed with
endoscopy. Over half of the patients who elected to enter surveillance
were able to maintain their kidney and avoid extirpative surgery. The
price for this is high, in terms of repeated procedures, but motivated
patients benefit. The take home message is that even in the presence
of high grade, multifocal or large volume disease, kidneys can be preserved.
Dr.
J. Stuart Wolf Jr.
Associate Professor of Urology
University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA
Evaluation of synchronous twin pulse technique for shock wave
lithotripsy: determination of optimal parameters for in vitro stone fragmentation
Sheir KZ, Zabihi N, Lee D, Teichman JM, Rehman J, Sundaram CP, Heimbach
D, Hesse A, Delvecchio F, Zhong P, Preminger GM, Clayman RV
From the Urology and Nephrology Center, Mansoura University (KZS), Mansoura,
Egypt; Division of Urology, University of Texas Health Science Center
(NZ, JMT), San Antonio, Texas; Department of Urology, College of Medicine,
University of California-Irvine Medical Center (DL, RVC), Irvine, California;
Division of Urology, Washington University School of Medicine (JR, CPS),
St. Louis, Missouri; Department of Urology, Section of Experimental Urology,
University of Bonn (DH, AH), Bonn, Germany; and Department of Mechanical
Engineering and Materials Science, Duke Comprehensive Kidney Stone Center
and Division of Urology/Department of Surgery, Duke University Medical
Center (FD, PZ, GMP), Durham, North Carolina, USA
J Urol. 2003; 170: 2190-4
- Purpose:
The Twinheads extracorporeal shock wave lithotriptor (THSWL) is composed
of 2 identical shock wave generators and reflectors. One reflector is
under the table and the other is over the table with a variable angle
between the axes of the 2 reflectors. The 2 reflectors share a common
second focal point, making it possible to deliver an almost synchronous
twin pulse to the targeted stone. We studied the optimal parameters
for in vitro stone fragmentation.
-
Materials and Methods:
Two types of 1 cm artificial stones were used, namely Bon(n)-stones
of 3 compositions (75% calcium oxalate monohydrate [COM] plus 25% uric
acid, struvite and cystine) and plaster of Paris. The parameters tested
were shock wave number (100, 500 and 1,000), shock wave power (8, 11
and 14 kV) and angle between the reflector axes (67, 90 and 105 degrees).
After the optimal parameters were determined, we studied the disintegrative
efficacy of THSWL for 3 types of human urinary calculi, including COM,
calcium hydrogen phosphate (brushite) and cystine. Each stone received
1,000 twin shock waves at 14 kV with an angle of 90 degrees between
the reflectors. All experiments were done using a rate of 60 twin shock
waves per minute. Following lithotripsy stone fragments were processed
and sized. The ratio of the weight of fragments greater than 2 mm-to-total
weight of all fragments was calculated.
-
Results:
Optimal stone fragmentation results for THSWL were obtained with the
maximum number of shock waves (1,000) and full power (14 kV). There
was no significant statistical difference in fragment size or the ratio
of fragments greater than 2 mm with the use of different angles except
for cystine and plaster of Paris calculi, for which the right angle
was most effective. At application of the optimal parameters to human
stones THSWL produced small fragment size for COM and cystine stones,
while brushite stones were not fragmented to the same extent.
-
Conclusions: The
efficacy of synchronous twin pulse technology improves as the number
of shock waves and power increase. A 90-degree angle between the shock
wave reflectors is advantageous for certain stones (that is cystine
and plaster of Paris) but it is not a factor for other stone compositions.
THSWL has satisfactory disintegrative efficacy for human stones, especially
COM and cystine calculi.
- Editorial
Comment
There are currently 2 dual-head lithotriptors available: the Twinheads
(FMD) and the Duet (Direx). In this study, the Twinheads was used to
fragment 4 types of artificial stones and 3 types of human urinary calculi.
The results of dual head lithotripsy were intriguing, although the assessment
of any superiority of this type of lithotripsy over other types is only
through comparison of these results to those in other studies (using
methods similar to the ones in this study, by many of the same investigators,
brushite stones were found to be resistant to several standard lithotriptors
while these same stones fragmented well with dual head lithotripsy).
It is not clear if any advantage of lithotripsy with the Twinheads machine
owes to the same cavitation bubble interaction investigated by Zhong
and associates (1) in their studies of dual lithotripsy. Moreover, the
other dual head lithotriptor currently available (Duet, from Direx)
can be set to either synchronous or asynchronous firing, and thus might
provide different results. It remains to be seen if dual head lithotriptors
will prove better, in terms of either efficacy or safety, than standard
ones, but dual lithotripsy might well be the next big thing in shock
wave lithotripsy.
Reference
1. Zhong P, Cocks FH, Cioanta I, Preminger GM: Controlled, forced collapse
of cavitation bubbles for improved stone fragmentation during shock wave
lithotripsy. J Urol. 1997; 158: 2323-8.
Dr.
J. Stuart Wolf Jr.
Associate Professor of Urology
University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA
IMAGING
Radiologic
features of Castleman’s disease occupying the renal sinus
Nishie A., Yoshimitsu K, Irie H, Aibe H, Tajima T, Shinozaki K, Nakayama
T, Kakihara D, Naito S, Ono M, Muranaka T, Honda H
From the Department of Clinical Radiology and Urology, Graduate School
of Medical Sciences, Kyushu University, Maidashi, Higashi-ku Fukuoka,
Department of Radiology Kitakyushu Municipal Medical Center, Kokurakita-ku
Kitakyushu and National Kyusyu Medical Center, Chuo-ku Fukuoka, Japan
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2003; 181: 1037-40
- Objective:
Our purpose was to describe the radiologic findings in five abnormalities
in three patients with Castleman’s disease occupying the renal
sinus.
-
Conclusion:
Common findings such as mild homogeneous enhancement passing through
the mass of the collecting system with mild hydronephrosis on contrast-enhanced
CT and hypointense signal on T2-weighted images were obtained. Castleman’s
disease may be considered in a differential diagnosis of a mass occupying
the renal sinus, although it is difficult to differentiate from malignant
lymphoma.
Abstract
Edited
-
Purpose:
To describe the radiologic findings in five abnormalities in three patients
with Castleman’s disease occupying the renal sinus.
-
Materials and Methods:
We report three patients (two men, one woman; 65 – 73 years old;
mean, 69 years old) with proven Castleman’s disease involving
the renal sinus. In one patient, the mass was unilateral; in the other
two, it was bilateral. All five masses were diagnosed histologically
at nephrectomy or open surgical biopsy. The histologic types included
the mixed form in one patient and the plasma cell type in the other
two patients. No lesions, other than those in the renal sinus, were
detected in any patient during a radiologic examination of the entire
body. One of the three patients was symptomatic (weight loss); the other
two were asymptomatic. CT, MRI and angiographic examinations were performed.
- Results:
The five masses, in three patients, ranged in maximal diameter from
3.0 to 4.5 cm (average diameter, 3.9 cm). All masses had relatively
well-defined margins except on the anterior side, where irregular margins
were seen. All lesions showed slightly higher attenuation than renal
parenchyma on unenhanced CT images and mild homogeneous enhancement
on the early phase images. The enhancement persisted to the delayed
phase. However, the attenuation of the masses after injection of the
contrast agent never approached that of normal renal parenchyma. As
a result, all masses showed lower attenuation than renal parenchyma.
Moreover, mild hydronephrosis, which was detected as blunting of the
calices, was seen in all kidneys associated with a mass in the renal
sinus, and the collecting system passed through the masses without being
obstructed. On MR imaging, three masses, in two patients, had homogeneous
and isohypointense signal relative to that of the renal cortex on T1-weighted
images. On T2-weighted images, all masses were homogeneous and hypointense
in signal compared with that of the renal cortex. Angiography was performed
in one patient. No definite vascular staining was seen at the renal
sinus. Both the left renal artery and the left renal vein were patent,
and no irregularity of the vascular wall was seen.
- Conclusion:
Common findings such as mild homogeneous enhancement passing
through the mass of the collecting system with mild hydronephrosis on
contrast-enhanced CT and hypointense signal on T2-weighted images were
obtained. Castleman’s disease may be considered in a differential
diagnosis of a mass occupying the renal sinus, although it is difficult
to differentiate from malignant lymphoma.
- Editorial
Comment
The abstract of this paper was editorially prepared with the purpose
of to call the attention for this relatively uncommon pathological entity,
which only recently has been more frequently recognized. Castleman’s
disease is an uncommon type of hyperplasia of lymphoid follicles that
only sporadically occurs in the abdomen and pelvis. Histologically,
this disease can be divided into 3: the hyaline vascular type, which
is more common (90% of cases), the plasma cell type and the mixed form.
It may present as asymptomatic involvement of one lymph node group (unicentric)
or as a multicentric disease with systemic symptoms. Unlike localized
disease, for which surgical excision is curative regardless of the histological
type, multicentric disease often necessitates aggressive systemic therapy
and portends a poor outcome. The most frequently sites of involvement
are: chest (67-70%); neck (14-40%); retroperitoneum (paraaortic or pararenal
space, 5-9%) and mesentery.
The most frequent appearance of abdominal or pelvic Castleman disease
is of a single, well-defined enhancing mass simulating either bulky
adenopathy, primary retroperitoneal tumor or lymphoma. When the mass
occurs in the pararenal space can be associated with hydronephrosis.
Calcification is seen in about 30% of the cases. Castleman’s disease,
although rare, should be included in the differential diagnosis of an
isolated well defined solid mass in the retroperitoneum or a soft tissue
mass occurring in the renal sinus or in the pararenal space.
Dr.
Adilson Prando
Department of Radiology
Vera Cruz Hospital
Campinas, São Paulo, Brazil
Helical
CT for nephrolithiasis and ureterolithiasis: comparison of conventional
and reduced radiation-dose techniques
Heneghan JP, McGuire KA, Leder RA, DeLong DM, Yoshizumi T, Nelson RC
From the Department of Radiology, Duke University Medical Center, Durham,
NC
Radiology. 2003; 229: 575-80
- Purpose:
To determine the accuracy of unenhanced helical computed tomography
(CT) performed at reduced milliampere-second, and therefore at a reduced
patient radiation dose, by using conventional unenhanced helical CT
as the standard.
-
Materials and Methods:
Fifty patients with acute flank pain who weighed less than 200 lb (90
kg) were prospectively recruited for this study. Conventional helical
CT scans were obtained with patients in the prone position by using
5-mm-thick sections, 140 kVp, 135-208 mAs (mean, 160 mAs), and a pitch
of 1.5 (single-detector row CT) or 0.75 (multi-detector row CT, 4 x
5-mm detector configuration). Conventional CT was immediately followed
by low-dose scanning, whereby the tube current was reduced to 100 mA
(mean, 76 mAs). All other technical parameters and anatomic coverage
remained constant. Three independent readers who were blinded to patient
identity interpreted the scans in random order. The observers noted
the location, size, and number of calculi; secondary signs of obstruction;
and other clinically relevant findings. High- and low-dose scans were
compared by using paired t tests and the signed rank test.
-
Results:
Calculi were found in 33 (66%) patients; 25 (50%) had renal calculi
and 19 (38%) had an obstructing ureteral calculus. The accuracy rates
(averaged over the three readers) for determining the various findings
on the low-dose scan compared with the high-dose scan were as follows:
nephrolithiasis, 91%; ureterolithiasis, 94%; obstruction, 91%; and normal
findings, 92%. When interpretations between readers were compared, agreement
rates were 90%-95% for standard-dose scans and 90%-92% for reduced-dose
scans (P > .5). Uncomplicated mild diverticulitis was found in three
patients. No other clinically important abnormality was identified.
A reduction in the tube current to 100 mA resulted in a dose reduction
of 25% for multi-detector row CT and 42% for single-detector row CT.
- Conclusion:
In patients who weighed less than 200 lb, unenhanced helical
CT performed at a reduced tube current of 100 mA, and therefore at a
reduced patient dose, resulted in scans of high accuracy.
- Editorial
Comment
There is no doubt regarding the crescent acceptance of the unenhanced
helical computed tomography (UHCT) for the investigation of patient
with acute flank pain and suspected of having urolithiasis. Although
UHCT confers diagnostic advantages and avoids the risks of intravenous
contrast medium, this should be considered against the increased radiation
dose to the patient (particularly to the gonads). Depending on the protocol
used, the average dose of an intravenous urography (IVU) vary from 1.5
to 2.0 mSV while for UCHT the effective dose is usually 4.7 mSV. In
other words the total dose of radiation of non-optimized UHCT protocol
confers a total dose, which is about three times that of an IVU. This
study deals with a very important issue in radiology today, which is
how to decrease radiation dose to the patients. This issue became more
crucial among radiologists after the introduction of the multidetector
row CT (MDCT). This diagnostic procedure has become widely used, particularly
in the USA, and has been proven to be a valuable tool for various indications.
A major issue using this new modality is the inherent risk of applying
increased radiation exposure, when compared to single-slice CT or other
imaging modalities. Fortunately, radiologists are now able to save radiation
exposure from the use of MDCT by choosing optimized exposure parameters
or its superior dose efficiency in comparison to single-slice CT. The
use of intelligent tools in these modern equipments, such as ECG- or
body shape-based real-time dose modulation, can further reduce the radiation
dose.
As we can see all efforts are been doing now by radiologists in order
to perform a low-dose CT protocol. While acquiring thin slices with
high spatial resolution, we can reduce the dose to similar values as
in conventional radiography, especially when examining under high-contrast
conditions. Using all these various options available, radiation exposure
can sometimes even be lower than using a conventional single-slice helical
CT. By using low dose-CT protocol we can reach similar sensitivity,
specificity and accuracy. For the detection of urolithiasis, for example,
low dose CT protocol is superior to IVU and confers a total dose of
2.8 mSV, which is about double that for IVU and about 75% and 50% of
that for non-optimized UHCT protocols. Recently these low dose noncontrast
CT protocols has been shown to be useful also for the diagnosis of stones
in pregnant women and children.
Dr.
Adilson Prando
Department of Radiology
Vera Cruz Hospital
Campinas, São Paulo, Brazil
UROGENITAL
TRAUMA
Does tachycardia correlate with hypotension after trauma?
Victorino GP, Battistella FD, Wisner DH.
Department of Surgery, University of California, San Francisco-East Bay,
Oakland, California 94602, USA
J Am Coll Surg. 2003; 196: 679-84
Comment in: J Am Coll Surg. 2003; 197: 697
-
Background:
Tachycardia is believed to be closely associated with hypotension and
is often listed as an important sign in the initial diagnosis of hemorrhagic
shock, but the correlation between heart rate and hypotension remains
unproved.
-
Study Design:
Data were collected from all trauma patients, 16 to 49 years old, presenting
to our university-based trauma center between July 1988 and January
1997. Moribund patients with a systolic blood pressure < or =50 or
heart rate < or = 40 and patients with significant head or spinal
cord injuries were excluded. Tachycardia was defined as a heart rate
> or = 90 and hypotension as a systolic blood pressure < 90.
-
Results:
Hypotension was present in 489 of the 14,325 admitted patients that
met the entry criteria. Of the hypotensive patients, 35% (169) were
not tachycardic. Tachycardia was present in 39% of patients with systolic
blood pressure 120 mmHg. Hypotensive patients with tachycardia had a
higher mortality (15%) compared with hypotensive patients who were not
tachycardic (2%, P = 0.003). Logistic regression analysis revealed tachycardia
to be independently associated with hypotension (p = 0.0004), but receiver
operating curve analysis demonstrated that the sensitivity and specificity
of heart rate for predicting hypotension is poor.
-
Conclusions:
Tachycardia is not a reliable sign of hypotension after trauma. Although
tachycardia was independently associated with hypotension, its sensitivity
and specificity limit its usefulness in the initial evaluation of trauma
victims. Absence of tachycardia should not reassure the clinician about
the absence of significant blood loss after trauma. Patients who are
both hypotensive and tachycardic have an associated increased mortality
and warrant careful evaluation.
Inconsistent finding of tachycardia in World War II combat casualties
Bellamy RF
Washington, DC, USA
J Am Coll Surg. 2003; 197: 697
- The article
by Victorino and colleagues is a welcome reminder that tachycardia does
not always accompany severe hemorrhage (1). It is of more than historical
interest that American military surgeons recognized the inconsistent
presence of tachycardia in wounded soldiers during World War II in some
of the earliest clinical investigations carried out on traumatized humans.
These data were published in the volume entitled The Physiologic Effects
of Wounds (2), which is part of the Surgeon General of the Army history
of medicine and surgery in World War II. I have summarized some of the
more applicable hemodynamic data from Table 8, page 34, and Table 9,
page 35, in Table 1, following, although this is no substitute for reading
the entire chapter, “Initial State of Entry to Hospital.”
On average, the casualties (n = 106) were studied some 6 hours after
trauma and before the beginning of resuscitation, though some had been
given several units of plasma and almost all had received morphine.
The most common injuries found in those in severe shock were traumatic
amputations, extensively comminuted open extremity fractures, and penetrating
thoracic injuries. Measurements of blood volume using a dye dilution
methodology were performed in about half of the study population (page
56). Estimated average blood volume losses, as a function of degree
of shock, were: none, 14.4%; slight, 20.7%; moderate, 34.3%; and severe,
45.9%. The authors concluded with the following observation (page 34):
“The finding that the average as well as the minimum and maximum
pulse rates was the same in all degrees of shock was surprising. It
is of interest that even patients judged to be in severe shock can have
a pulse rate as low as 60 beats per minute.” Data such as these
and those reported in the article by Victorino and colleagues (1) speak
strongly in favor of modifying the long-standing ATLS teaching on the
relation of heart rate to hemorrhage.

References
1. Victorino GP, Battistella FD, Wisner DH: Does tachycardia correlate
with hypotension after trauma? J Am Coll Surg. 2003; 196: 679–84.
2. The Board for the Study of the Severely Wounded. The Physiologic Effects
of Wounds. Washington, DC: Office of The Surgeon General; Department of
the Army; 1952; 21-74.
-
Editorial Comment
A major part of modern trauma surgery is determining when patients are
at risk of death or disability from ongoing blood loss. This is particularly
important when determining if a patient needs open exploration for renal
trauma. Most surgeons use a combination of serial hematocrit designations,
vital signs, and “clinical judgment” to determine when patients
are losing blood rapidly. Two excellent recent reports shed light on
the utility (or lack of utility) of an increased heart rate (tachycardia)
in the evaluation of the injured patient. Basically, they determine
that tachycardia is not a universally reliable indicator of blood loss.
Other determinants such as serial hematocrit or hypotension must be
used instead.
In the first report, 14,000 trauma patients were analyzed. While increased
heart rate did correlate with hypotension and blood loss, it had poor
sensitivity and specificity. The study also found that up to 35% of
patients exhibited bradycardia and not tachycardia as a sign of severe
bleeding.
The second publication on this subject is a letter, which supports the
findings of the Victorino et al. study by invoking a similar study of
war wounded from 50 years ago. In this review of 106 battle casualties,
the range of pulse rates between those with no blood loss or shock compared
to those with moderate and severe blood loss / shock were quite similar.
Just as in the more modern series, the overlap made tachycardia nearly
useless as a universally-reliable indicator of even the most severe
bleeding. Although heart rate should not be completely ignored in the
trauma patient, it must be realized that if the heart rate does not
correlate with other signs of blood loss, further investigation is warranted.
As a single determinant of blood loss, tachycardia is simply not very
useful.
Dr.
Richard A. Santucci
Assistant Professor of Urology
Wayne State University
Detroit, Michigan, USA
Validity of computerized tomography in blunt renal trauma
Bschleipfer T, Kallieris D, Hallscheidt P, Hauck EW, Weidner W, Pust RA
Department of Urology, Ulm Military Hospital, Ulm / Donau, Germany
J Urol. 2003;170: 2475-9
-
Purpose:
Improved imaging techniques and new therapeutic possibilities require
rethinking the indication for laparotomy with regard to blunt renal
trauma. Refined classification systems would facilitate the decision
relating to therapy but they are based on knowledge of the imaging accuracy
of computerized tomography (CT). We evaluated the validity of the CT
depiction of renal injuries.
- Materials
and Methods: A total of 42 porcine kidneys were subjected to
traumatization of various degrees. They then underwent CT examination
and were subsequently cross-dissected into slices 3 mm thick. The comparative
evaluation involved 2,080 CT images and 1,819 macroscopic sectional
views, which showed 3,521 and 3,778 individual lesions, respectively.
-
Results:
Using CT the overall extent of injury in renal trauma was only slightly
overrated at an average of 15% higher than that seen on macroscopy.
Simple linear lesions tended to be over assessed and parenchymal destruction
tended to be under assessed. Central lesions were depicted more frequently
than peripheral lesions. CT of medullary lesions and parenchymal detachment
was not feasible.
- Conclusions:
CT of the kidney enables the distinction of different kinds of lesions
and their localization well. Pelvic structures or vessels can imitate
linear lesions. However, this imaging procedure can be used as a basis
for refining categorization systems for blunt renal trauma. It can also
be used to obtain a large quantity of lesion data for biomechanical
investigations.
- Editorial
Comment
Computed tomography (CT) is the undisputed state of the art when it
comes to evaluating renal injuries. However, despite wide use, and a
number of clinical studies supporting its accuracy, few experimental
studies have been published which evaluate the accuracy of CT scanning
in renal trauma. Although this study has some shortcomings inherent
in the use of animals (experimental model of renal injury may or may
not model human injuries well, pig kidneys may not be identical to human
kidneys, etc.) it is a valuable experimental look at the correlation
between CT imaging and known renal injuries.
In this study, 42 pig kidneys underwent experimental injury and over
2,000 CT images of the kidneys were compared to macroscopic sections
of the injured renal units. They concluded: 1) CT overestimates the
degree of injury (as scored by the authors own scoring system) by only
15%, 2) Parenchymal disruption is slightly overestimated because of
the confounding appearance of normal renal tissue such as blood vessels.
The authors made no attempt to model vascular injury or penetrating
injury. Also, they did not attempt to validate CT in evaluating renal
trauma in line that corresponded to the 5-part American Association
for the Surgery of Trauma (AAST) Organ Injury Severity Scale for the
Kidney. However, this study appears to lend experimental support to
the common clinical practice of using CT to accurately determine the
extent of blunt renal injury.
Dr.
Richard A. Santucci
Assistant Professor of Urology
Wayne State University
Detroit, Michigan, USA
PATHOLOGY
Visual
estimate of percent of carcinoma predicts recurrence after radical prostatectomy
Manoharan M, Civantos F, Kim SS, Gomez P, Soloway MS
Department of Urology, University of Miami School of Medicine, Florida,
USA
J Urol. 2003; 170: 1194-8
-
Purpose:
Tumor volume is an important prognosticator for predicting prostate
cancer recurrence following radical prostatectomy (RP). We assessed
the ability of the visual estimate of the percent of carcinoma (VEPC)
to predict recurrence.
- Methods
and Materials: As performed by 1 surgeon (MSS), 1,114 men underwent
radical prostatectomy between 1992 and February 2002. Patients who had
less than 12 months of followup, who underwent salvage RP or in whom
VEPC was not assessed in the pathology specimen were excluded. VEPC
and other clinical variables were analyzed. We performed univariate
analysis using the Kaplan-Meier log rank test. Multivariate analysis
using Cox proportional hazards regression was performed.
-
Results:
A total of 692 patients with a mean age of 61 +/- 7 years met the criteria
for this analysis. Mean followup was 52 +/- 30 months. Of the patients
17% had biochemical recurrence. Mean VEPC was 25% and 13% in those with
and without recurrence, respectively. On univariate analysis all variables
were significant predictors of recurrence. However, multivariate analysis
showed that the only significant predictors of recurrence were patient
age, initial prostate specific antigen 10 ng/ml or greater, RP Gleason
8 to 10, extraprostatic extension, seminal vesicle involvement and VEPC.
Based on disease-free survival curves patients were stratified into
3 broad groups, namely low, intermediate and high volume. The HR for
biochemical recurrence was 2.1 for the intermediate VEPC group (9.1%
to 20%) and 2.7 for the high VEPC group (greater than 20%). In the reference
group it was less than 9% (low volume).
-
Conclusions:
VEPC is a simple and inexpensive method that is an independent predictor
of recurrence after RP.
-
Editorial Comment
One of the most controversial aspects of the pathologic assessment of
radical prostatectomy specimens is the measurement of the tumor volume.
Nevertheless, as yet, there are no defined standards for reporting the
cancer volume in prostatectomy specimens. Some institutions have calculated
the tumor volume accurately, using computer-assisted image analysis
systems. Because this method is not feasible for the routine clinical
practice, other investigators have proposed alternative simpler means
for measuring tumor volume, including the diameter of largest tumor
focus, the number of tumor foci, the number of involved blocks, the
percentage of blocks involved, the use of a 3.0 mm squares grid, or
naked eye examination of the glass slides after the pathologist had
circled all microscopically identifiable foci of carcinoma with a marking
pen (pathologist’s percentage estimate). Recently, we proposed
for estimating tumor volume a simple point-count method accessible to
all general pathologists working in routine pathology laboratories (Int
Braz J Urol. 2003; 29: 113-120).
In the present study, tumor volume was an independent predictor of recurrence
after radical prostatectomy. Epstein et al. (J Urol. 1993; 149: 1478-1481)
analyzed 185 men who underwent radical retropubic prostatectomy for
clinical stage B adenocarcinoma of the prostate. Although tumor volume
predicted progression, in a stepwise regression analysis it did not
provide independent prognostic information. The authors conclude that
although an accurate preoperative assessment of tumor volume remains
desirable for the management of patients with prostate cancer, the study
demonstrated that measurement of tumor volume in radical prostatectomy
specimens need not be performed as part of the routine pathological
analysis of radical prostatectomy specimens, since it does not provide
additional information beyond that of Gleason score and the status of
capsular margins.
In a recent paper to be presented in the USCAP meeting in Vancouver
and to be published as an abstract in the January (2004) issue of Modern
Pathology, we studied 123 patients submitted to radical prostatectomy
for clinical stages T1c or T2. Using the point-count method for estimating
tumor volume, we concluded that shorter time to progression following
radical prostatectomy correlated with preoperative PSA and Gleason score
but not with tumor extension.
In a paper addressing prognostic factors in prostate cancer by the College
of American Pathologists (Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2000; 124: 995-1000),
tumor volume was considered category II, that is, needs confirmation.
Dr.
Athanase Billis
Full-Professor of Pathology
State University of Campinas, Unicamp
Campinas, São Paulo, Brazil
Collecting duct carcinoma of the kidney: a clinicopathological study of
9 cases
Peyromaure M, Thiounn N, Scotte F, Vieillefond A, Debre B, Oudard S
Department of Urology, Cochin Hospital, Paris, France
J Urol. 2003; 170: 1138-40
-
Purpose:
Collecting duct carcinoma (CDC) of the kidney is a rare variant that
is associated with an extremely poor prognosis. We report our experience
with this variety of cancer in the last 9 years.
- Materials
and Methods: From 1993 to 2002, 9 patients with CDC were treated
at our institution. The diagnosis of CDC was made by a nephrectomy specimen
in 8 cases and by renal biopsy in 1. Tumor characteristics, and patient
treatment and outcome are reported.
- Results:
At presentation 1 T1N0M0, 1 T3N0M0, 3 T3N+M0 and 4 T3N+M+ tumors were
seen. Mean followup was 13.6 months. Five patients received no complementary
treatment. The patient with the T1N0M0 tumor remained free of disease
13 months after nephrectomy and the one with T3N0M0 tumor remained free
of disease at 17 months. A patient with a T3N+M+ tumor experienced progression
at 1 month, local recurrence at 17 months and was then lost to followup.
The 2 other patients with T3N+M0 and T3N+M+ disease, respectively, progressed
rapidly and were lost to followup after 5 months. One patient with a
T3N+M0 neoplasm received immunotherapy and died after 24 months, while
the other with T3N+M0 disease was treated with oral prednisolone and
died after 5 months. Finally, 2 patients with T3N+M+ disease received
chemotherapy, consisting of 1,250 mg/m2 gemcitabine on days 1 and 8,
and 70 mg/m2 cisplatin on day 1. Each patient achieved an objective
response after 3 chemotherapy cycles and remained disease-free 27 and
9 months after nephrectomy, respectively.
-
Conclusions:
CDC is an aggressive variety of kidney neoplasm that is often associated
with nodal and visceral metastases at presentation. Our data suggest
that combined gemcitabine and cisplatin chemotherapy may be the best
therapeutic option for patients with this tumor.
- Editorial
Comment
Collecting duct carcinoma accounts for approximately 1 per cent of renal
cell neoplasms. In spite of its rarity is considered one of the most
aggressive variants of renal tumors. No consistent pattern of genetic
abnormalities has been established. The morphologic features are characterized
by irregular tubules reminiscent of the Bellini collecting ducts set
in a desmoplastic stroma. An affinity for the Ulex europaeus lectin
supports a collecting duct origin for this tumor.
A differential diagnosis is with renal urothelial carcinoma with glandular
differentiation. Favors this latter diagnosis squamous differentiation
and dysplastic epithelium or in situ carcinoma in the pelvic urothelium.
Another differential diagnosis is the recently described low-grade mucinous
and spindle cell carcinoma of the kidney (Mod Pathol. 2002; 15: 182A).
Microscopically, it shows tubular structures reminiscent of the thin
segment of the loop of Henle. It is a tumor with good prognosis and
a striking female preponderance. The immunohistochemistry displays proximal
and distal nephronic markers.
A variant of collecting duct carcinoma is the medullary carcinoma of
the kidney. This variant was described by Davis, Mostofi and Sesterhen
(Am J Surg Pathol. 1995; 19: 1-11) which is believed to arise from the
collecting ducts of the renal medulla and is associated with sickle
cell trait. The authors coined this tumor as the seventh sickle cell
nephropathy. The other 6 are hematuria, papillary necrosis, nephrotic
syndrome, renal infarction, inability to concentrate urine and pyelonephritis.
Dr.
Athanase Billis
Full-Professor of Pathology
State University of Campinas, Unicamp
Campinas, São Paulo, Brazil
INVESTIGATIVE
UROLOGY
Analysis
of the modifications in the composition of bladder glycosaminoglycan and
collagen as a consequence of changes in sex hormones associated with puberty
or oophorectomy in female rats
Cabral CA, Sampaio FJ, Cardoso LE
Urogenital Research Unit, State University of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
J Urol. 2003;170: 2512-6
- Purpose:
The effects of female sex hormones on rat vesical extracellular matrix
were evaluated by analyzing glycosaminoglycan (GAG) and collagen composition
under different hormonal conditions.
-
Materials and Methods:
Bladders were obtained from Wistar rats, including young prepubertal
females at age 30 days (YF), and adult intact females (AF), adult oophorectomized
females (AOF), adult males and adult sham operated females at age 120
days. Oophorectomy and sham operation were performed at age 30 days.
Bladders were analyzed for total GAG and collagen concentration per
mg dry tissue and for the contents of GAG species, as determined by
agarose electrophoresis and reported as the percent of total sulfated
GAG.
-
Results:
Collagen concentration in AF (54.80 +/- 4.60 microg/mg) was different
from that in YF (34.52 +/- 5.29 microg/mg, p <0.001) and AOF (63.25
+/- 3.51 microg/mg, p <0.001). GAG concentration in AF (0.71 +/-
0.18 microg/mg) was different from that in YF (0.45 +/- 0.07 microg/mg,
p <0.001) and males (0.46 +/- 0.10 microg/mg, p <0.001). The GAG
species detected were dermatan sulfate and heparan sulfate. Dermatan
sulfate content in AF (90.9% +/- 2.8%) was different from that in YF
(86.6% +/- 2.4%, p <0.005), AOF (87.9% +/- 2.1%, p <0.005) and
males (87.7% +/- 4.7%, p <0.005). Heparan sulfate content in AF was
9.1% +/- 2.8%, which differed from that in YF (13.4% +/- 2.4%, p <0.025)
and AOF (11.2% +/- 2.9%, p <0.025).
-
Conclusions:
Extracellular matrix of the female rat bladder undergoes marked remodeling
during normal growth up to early adulthood with important consequences
for vesical viscoelastic properties. Also, oophorectomy performed at
a prepubertal age may lead to greater vesical wall stiffness.
-
Editorial Comment
Sex hormones have been shown to variously affect the synthesis of extracellular
matrix (ECM) molecules by mesenchymal cells such as fibroblasts and
smooth muscles cells, both in vivo and in vitro. This effect is exerted
on several tissues and organs and has, in many cases, a normal regulatory
role. The ECM may also undergo abnormal modifications, and these have
been implicated with many diseases, including urinary tract disorders.
In the present study, the effects of female sex hormones on the biochemical
composition of vesical glycosaminoglycans (GAG) and collagen in rats
under different hormonal conditions were evaluated.
The results show that variations in the plasma levels of female sex
hormones parallel different changes in the ECM composition of the rat
bladder wall. During the normal growth of the female rat from a pre-pubertal
age to early adulthood, there are marked increases in both total GAG
and collagen concentrations, together with a small increase in dermatan
sulfate and a more important decrease in heparan sulfate. Compared to
the intact adult females, the bladders from oophorectomized adult females
had a slightly higher collagen concentration but presented no change
in total GAG, whereas the dermatan sulfate and heparan sulfate contents
were decreased and increased, respectively, which may lead to greater
vesical wall stiffness. Bladders from adult males differ from those
of females of comparable age in that they have less total GAG, and hence
a higher collagen: GAG ratio, and slightly less dermatan sulfate. In
conclusion, this work demonstrates that the ECM of the female rat bladder
undergoes a marked remodeling during normal growth up, which can lead
to important consequences for vesical viscoelastic properties.
Dr. Francisco J.B. Sampaio
Full-Professor and Chair, Urogenital Research Unit
State University of Rio de Janeiro
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Experimental
varicocele induces testicular germ cell apoptosis in the rat
Barqawi A, Caruso A, Meacham RB
From the Division of Urology, Department of Surgery, University of Colorado
School of Medicine, Denver, Colorado, USA
J Urol. 2004; 171: 501-3
-
Purpose:
We evaluated the impact of experimentally created varicocele on ipsilateral
and contralateral testicular germ cells in the rat.
- Materials
and Methods: Experimental left varicocele was created by partial
ligation of the left renal vein in 17 adult male Sprague-Dawley rats.
An additional 5 rats that underwent laparotomy and renal vein handling
without ligation served as sham surgical controls. Five rats that underwent
no surgical or other intervention served as a control group. Rats were
sacrificed 7 (5), 14 (5) or 28 (7) days following varicocele creation.
Germ cell apoptosis was quantified using a TUNEL assay. The results
of this assay are expressed as the number of apoptotic germ cell nuclei
per seminiferous tubular cross section. The presence of apoptosis was
confirmed by cellular ultrastructure evaluation using transmission electron
microscopy.
- Results:
Control and sham animals were found to have a mean of 0.05 and 0.15
apoptotic germ cells per seminiferous tubular cross section, respectively.
Rats sacrificed 7, 14 and 28 days after varicocele creation were found
to have 0.15, 0.23 and 0.27 apoptotic germ cells per tubule in the ipsilateral
testis, and 0.14, 0.16 and 0.17 apoptotic germ cells per tubule in the
contralateral testis, respectively. Compared with control animals a
statistically significant increase in the number of apoptotic germ cells
per tubular cross section was noted 14 days following varicocele creation
in the ipsilateral testis (p < 0.05).
-
Conclusions:
The creation of experimental varicocele generated an increase in germ
cell apoptosis in the ipsilateral testis at 14 days compared with control
animals.
- Editorial
Comment
Until now, a precise relationship between varicocele and infertility
is yet to be clarified. The present study analyzed the testicular germ
cell apoptosis in the rat as consequence of experimentally induced varicocele.
The authors used an established animal model for the creation of testicular
varicocele for assessing the time impact of such a lesion on germ cell
apoptosis. The findings confirmed that the normal Sprague-Dawley rat
demonstrates low levels of germ cell apoptosis (0.05 apoptotic germ
cells per tubular cross section). Also, the animals subjected to laparotomy
without partial ligation of the renal vein demonstrated germ cell apoptosis
that was not statistically different from that in normal controls. On
the other hand, rats that underwent experimental varicocele creation
showed significantly increased levels of germ cell apoptosis in the
ipsilateral testis 14 days following varicocele creation.
Although the animal model of varicocele clearly differs from the clinical
varicocele seen in humans, the findings of the present study indicate
that experimental varicocele creation in the rat generates a time dependent
increase in germ cell apoptosis in the ipsilateral testis. These findings
may be the explanation of the mechanism by which varicocele exerts a
pathological influence on testicular function in a clinical setting.
Dr.
Francisco J.B. Sampaio
Full-Professor and Chair, Urogenital Research Unit
State University of Rio de Janeiro
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
RECONSTRUCTIVE UROLOGY
Flap
technology for reconstructions of urogenital organs
Ninkovic M, Dabernig W
From the Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, University
of Innsbruck, Innsbruck, Austria
Curr Opin Urol. 2003; 13: 483-8
- Purpose
of Review: The
purpose of this review is to summarize the different reconstructive
options for urogenital indications. The development of various flap
techniques to restore congenital and acquired urogenital defects is
presented.
- Recent
Findings: Various reconstructive techniques have been demonstrated
recently. On the basis of the reconstructive requirements, two main
techniques can be defined: the standard local or regional flap technique
(pedicled flap) and the more sophisticated microvascular free flap technique.
Free tissue transplantation (transfer) is a procedure that involves
microvascular transplantation of a flap (a fasciocutaneous, muscle or
composite flap) in one stage from a donor site in the body to a distant
recipient site. The viability of the transplanted flap is maintained
by microvascular anastomosis between the flap’s vessels (at least
one artery and one vein) and recipient vessels. Re-innervation and functioning
muscle contraction is achieved by suturing the vessels and a motor nerve
in the recipient area to a motor nerve of a free transplanted muscle.
After regeneration of the nerve and re-innervation of the transplanted
muscle, a functioning free transplanted muscle offers enough contractile
capacity and strength to replace the function of the missing muscles
at the recipient site. The technique of microvascular free tissue transfer
necessitates extensive experience in microvascular technique and this
approach could be efficiently applied in cooperation with other specialists.
Recent studies show the development and clinical application of these
new surgical techniques in urology (e.g. in the treatment of bladder
acontractility using innervated free latissimus dorsi muscle and in
the use of a free microvascular fillet lower leg flap for the reconstruction
of a large pelvic-floor defect).
-
Summary: Various
reconstructive requirements define the techniques for reconstruction.
The main principle is to obtain optimal anatomical and functional reconstruction
with minimal donor site morbidity. Depending on the etiology of the
defect, different reconstructive options are available to optimize the
reconstructive result. Optimal reconstruction might best be achieved
by adopting an interdisciplinary approach in which the primary objective
is to provide the best possible outcome for each patient. This review
presents the main indications for and principles of flap selection according
to the reconstructive requirements.
- Editorial
Comment
In reconstructive urology as in many other areas indications and possibilities
can be considerably improved by co-operation with other disciplines.
The current paper written by an expert plastic surgeon published in
an urological journal shows how sophisticated flap techniques can be
used in urologic surgery.
Another important aspect is the fact that pre-fabrication as seen by
these authors is an alternative for reconstruction of segments in the
urinary tract. Contrary to tissue engineering, where the organ is primarily
generated in the laboratory to be implanted into the body later on,
the pre-fabrication technique composes organs with one or several different
flaps in the body itself and transplants or transposes the finished
“product” to the desired location when it is ready to use.
When we look at the many open questions and problems that need to be
solved in tissue engineering before we can apply it on a large scale
in urology, pre-fabrication may be a way for a broader clinical use
in the nearer future.
Dr. Arnulf Stenzl
Professor and Chairman of Urology
Eberhard-Karls-University Tuebingen
Tuebingen, Germany
Improved
sphincter contractility after allogenic muscle-derived progenitor cell
injection into the denervated rat urethra
Cannon TW, Lee JY, Somogyi G, Pruchnic R, Smith CP, Huard J, Chancellor
MB
Department of Urology, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh,
Pennsylvania, USA
Urology. 2003; 62: 958-63
- Objectives:
To study the physiologic outcome of allogenic transplant of muscle-derived
progenitor cells (MDPCs) in the denervated female rat urethra.
-
Methods:
MDPCs were isolated from muscle biopsies of normal 6-week-old Sprague-Dawley
rats and purified using the preplate technique. Sciatic nerve-transected
rats were used as a model of stress urinary incontinence. The experimental
group was divided into three subgroups: control, denervated plus 20
microL saline injection, and denervated plus allogenic MDPCs (1 to 1.5
106 cells) injection. Two weeks after injection, urethral muscle strips
were prepared and underwent electrical field stimulation. The pharmacologic
effects of d-tubocurare, phentolamine, and tetrodotoxin on the urethral
strips were assessed by contractions induced by electrical field stimulation.
The urethral tissues also underwent immunohistochemical staining for
fast myosin heavy chain and CD4-activated lymphocytes.
-
Results:
Urethral denervation resulted in a significant decrease of the maximal
fast-twitch muscle contraction amplitude to only 8.77% of the normal
urethra and partial impairment of smooth muscle contractility. Injection
of MDPCs into the denervated sphincter significantly improved the fast-twitch
muscle contraction amplitude to 87.02% of normal animals. Immunohistochemistry
revealed a large amount of new skeletal muscle fiber formation at the
injection site of the urethra with minimal inflammation. CD4 staining
showed minimal lymphocyte infiltration around the MDPC injection sites.
- Conclusions:
Urethral denervation resulted in near-total abolishment of the skeletal
muscle and partial impairment of smooth muscle contractility. Allogenic
MDPCs survived 2 weeks in sciatic nerve-transected urethra with minimal
inflammation. This is the first report of the restoration of deficient
urethral sphincter function through muscle-derived progenitor cell tissue
engineering. MDPC-mediated cellular urethral myoplasty warrants additional
investigation as a new method to treat stress urinary incontinence.
- Editorial
Comment
The idea to enhance urinary sphincter function by injecting in vitro
cultivated cells into a dysfunctional sphincter is fascinating. This
group as well as others has presented experimental work showing the
possible benefit of such a procedure. The authors are the first ones
to provide a peer reviewed paper on the outcome of injecting in vitro
cultivated progenitor muscle cells. This work is remarkable with regards
to two aspects. Apart from an improvement of urethral sphincter function
by muscle-derived progenitor cell injection, it also demonstrates the
effect of urethral denervation. This denervation resulted not only in
a near total loss of function of the skeletal muscle (i.e. rhabdosphincter)
but also in a partial impairment of smooth muscle contractility. This
confirms clinical findings that autonomic nerve preservation may also
have a beneficial effect on urinary continence.
An improvement in sphincter tonus by injecting autologous muscle derived
progenitor cell injection has been demonstrated previously by another
group (Strasser et al., Eur Urol. 2003; 43: A 350). This work was carried
out in pigs, which in many ways have more similarity to the clinical
situation than rats. However, no peer reviewed published manuscript
exists yet.
As it seems we are entering a new period with regards to the treatment
of stress urinary incontinence. Instead of just injecting bulking agents
or passively closing the urethra with a silicone cuff, we may be able
to restore or improve remnant insufficient rhabdosphincter function.
Dr. Arnulf Stenzl
Professor and Chairman of Urology
Eberhard-Karls-University Tuebingen
Tuebingen, Germany
UROLOGICAL
ONCOLOGY
Fluid
intake and the risk of tumor recurrence in patients with superficial bladder
cancer
Donat SM, Bayuga S, Herr HW, Berwick M
Department of Urology, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, 1275 York
Avenue, New York, NY, 10021, USA
J Urol. 2003; 170: 1777-80
- Purpose:
High fluid intake has been associated with a decreased risk of bladder
cancer development in men. We evaluated whether higher fluid intake
can impact tumor recurrence rates in patients with superficial bladder
cancer.
- Materials
and Methods: We conducted a prospective single institution
analysis of fluid intake in 267 consecutive patients with superficial
bladder cancer undergoing routine bladder cancer surveillance between
January 1998 and December 2001. Fluid intake questionnaires, urine cytology
and physical examination were routinely performed at each surveillance
cystoscopy. Cytological and histological recurrences were recorded.
All patients had a minimum followup of 2 years.
-
Results: No
relationship between fluid intake and tumor recurrence was demonstrated.
Average daily fluid intake was 2,654 ml daily, which was well within
the highest protective level (more than 2,531 ml) previously reported.
However, multivariate analysis failed to show a protective effect against
recurrence at any level of fluid intake. Increasing age correlated with
decreased fluid intake (Pearson’s correlation coefficient -0.19,
p = 0.0015), but did not increase the risk of recurrence (p = 0.59).
Single fluid intake data correlated with the average of additional fluid
intakes (median 5 per patient) in the same patient (Pearson’s
correlation coefficient, 0.45, p < 0.0001). Of the study population
123 patients (46%) experienced 1 or more tumor recurrences (range 0
to 11) within a median followup of 2.6 years.
- Conclusions:
Our prospective study of fluid intake in patients with superficial bladder
cancer at risk for recurrence did not find any association between daily
fluid intake levels and tumor recurrence.
- Editorial
Comment
After having diagnosed and treated his superficial bladder cancer appropriately,
the urologist used to urge the patient to “drink a lot”.
However, under scientific conditions, this advice did not prove to be
well founded. The authors conducted a prospective study in 267 consecutive
patients, and their results told that fluid intake was not correlated
with tumor recurrences. However when looking into the data given in
this paper, the difference between all the patients with regard to fluid
intake was not high, the overall 24-hour fluid intake being 2.5 L. Fluid
intake of those with no recurrences was 2,550 mL and those with recurrences
was 2,640 mL. These data in mind it is highly unlikely, even if fluid
intake had an impact on tumor recurrences, that a difference of 100
mL per day might be the relevant quantity to have such enormous impact.
Dr. Andreas Böhle
Professor of Urology
HELIOS Agnes Karll Hospital
Bad Schwartau, Germany
Radiotherapy for men with isolated increase in serum prostate
specific antigen after radical prostatectomy
Macdonald OK, Schild SE, Vora SA, Andrews PE, Ferrigni RG, Novicki DE,
Swanson SK, Wong WW
Department of Radiation Oncology, Section of Urology, Mayo Clinic Scottsdale,
13400 E. Shea Boulevard, Scottsdale, AZ, 85259, USA
J Urol. 2003; 170: 1833-7
-
Purpose:
In this retrospective study we determined the results of salvage external
beam radiation therapy (RT) to the prostate bed for isolated increase
of serum prostate specific antigen (PSA) after radical prostatectomy.
-
Materials and Methods:
A total of 60 patients underwent RT for PSA failure after radical prostatectomy
from 1993 to 1999. Median followup was 51 months. Biochemical disease-free
survival (bDFS) with a serum PSA of 0.3 ng/mL or less was estimated
using the Kaplan-Meier method. Potential prognostic factors were evaluated
for significant associations with bDFS.
- Results:
Median PSA before RT was 0.69 ng/ml. Median radiation dose was 64.8
Gy. The 5-year actuarial bDFS was 45%. There were 32 patients with a
minimum followup of 4 years (median 73 months) who experienced a 5-year
bDFS rate of 43%. PSA before RT (p = 0.016), RT dose (p = 0.026), surgical
margin involvement (p = 0.017) and Gleason score (p = 0.018) were identified
as prognostic factors for bDFS. A significant association with bDFS
was present at 5 years of 65%, 34% and 0% for PSA before RT less than
0.6, 0.6 to 1.2, and greater than 1.2 ng/ml, respectively (p = 0.036).
Patients with PSA before RT less than 0.6 ng/ml and total RT dose greater
than 64.8 Gy had improved bDFS at 5 years compared to all others (77%
vs. 32%, p = 0.04). Of 60 patients 3 (5%) experienced chronic grade
3 toxicity.
- Conclusions:
Optimal benefit from salvage RT was achieved in patients with a PSA
less than 0.6 ng/ml and doses of RT greater than 64.8 Gy. Early treatment
with a sufficiently high dose of RT maximizes the potential for salvage.
- Editorial
Comment
This paper defines the timing and indication for adjuvant radiotherapy
after biochemical tumor recurrences following radical prostatectomy.
In conclusion, patients do better if treated at an PSA below 0.69 ng/ml,
with a local dose of at least 64.8 Gy, with Gleason scores below 7,
and, interestingly, with positive surgical margins. A possible explanation
for the letter fact is that patients with positive surgical margins
have a higher likelihood of localized microscopic residual disease in
the prostate bed. An increasing PSA would more easily indicate local
progression of that microscopic disease, whereas increasing PSA in the
margin negative group may indicate undetectable distant disease that
would not be treated effectively with radiotherapy to the prostate bed.
Altogether the results support an earlier the better approach to postoperative
radiotherapy.
Dr.
Andreas Böhle
Professor of Urology
HELIOS Agnes Karll Hospital
Bad Schwartau, Germany
Health related quality of life patterns in patients treated with
interstitial prostate brachytherapy for localized prostate cancer—data
from CaPSURE
Downs TM, Sadetsky N, Pasta DJ, Grossfeld GD, Kane CJ, Mehta SS, Carroll
PR, Lubeck DP
Department of Urology, Program in Urologic Oncology, Urologic Outcomes
Research Group, UCSF/Mt. Zion Comprehensive Cancer Center, University
of California San Francisco, 400 Parnassus Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94143,
USA
J Urol. 2003; 170: 1822-7
- Purpose:
We measured the impact brachytherapy monotherapy (BMT) has on general
and disease specific health related quality of life (HRQOL) compared
to patients treated with radical prostatectomy (RP).
-
Materials and Methods:
We studied 419 men with newly diagnosed prostate cancer who enrolled
in CaPSURE (Cancer of the Prostate Strategic Urological Research Endeavor)
database whose primary treatment was brachytherapy monotherapy (92)
or radical prostatectomy (327). The validated RAND 36-Item Health Survey
and the UCLA Prostate Cancer Index were used to measure HRQOL before
treatment and at 6-month intervals during the first 2 years after treatment.
-
Results:
Patients treated with BMT or RP did not differ greatly in general HRQOL
after treatment. Both treatment groups showed early functional impairment
in most general domains with scores returning to or approaching baseline
in most domains 18 to 24 months after treatment. Patients treated with
BMT had significantly higher urinary function scores at 0 to 6 months
after treatment (84.5, SD 18.7) than patients treated with RP (63.3,
SD 26.6). Urinary bother scores at 0 to 6 months after treatment were
not significantly different between patients treated with BMT (67.7,
SD 31.2) and those treated with RP (67.4, SD 29.1). Both treatment groups
had decreases in sexual function that did not return to pretreatment
levels.
-
Conclusions: Overall
BMT and RP are well tolerated procedures that cause mild changes in
general HRQOL. Disease specific HRQOL patterns are different in patients
treated with BMT or RP. Baseline and serial HRQOL measurements after
treatment can provide valuable information regarding expected quality
of life outcome after treatment for localized prostate cancer.
- Editorial
Comment
This paper nicely reflects the clinically well known pattern of side
effects of interstitial brachytherapy in relation to radical prostatectomy.
Patients treated with radical prostatectomy had urinary function change
scores greater than 15 points below baseline at all time intervals after
treatment, when differences of 5-10 points are thought to represent
a clinically significant change. The worst change score difference was
0-6 months after treatment (28.8 points below base line values). Significant
change score differences between the two groups of patients were detected
at all time intervals after treatment (p < 0.003). With brachytherapy,
significant bowel function change score differences were detected 0-12
month after treatment (3.8 – 13.6 points below baseline values).
By 18 months after treatment, no significant change score difference
was detected in patients with brachytherapy.
Significant group change score differences were detected at each time
interval for both sexual domains, namely sexual function and bother
(p < 0.02). Bowel impairment differences between patients treated
with brachytherapy or radical operative therapy were evident after the
first post treatment evaluations only.
In summary, these data clearly show the advantage, at least on a short
term basis within the first 2 years, with regard to side effects of
brachytherapy over radical prostatectomy. With the good long-term results
available now in the literature with regard to the therapeutic outcome,
brachytherapy indeed represents a valuable alternative of treatment
for localized prostate cancer.
Dr. Andreas Böhle
Professor of Urology
HELIOS Agnes Karll Hospital
Bad Schwartau, Germany
FEMALE
UROLOGY
Perioperative
complications: the first 140 polypropylene pubovaginal slings
Kobashi KC, Govier FE
The Continence Center at Virginia Mason, 1100 Ninth Avenue, Seattle, Washington
98101, USA
J Urol. 2003; 170: 1918-21
- Purpose:
Two widely used tensionless mid urethral slings currently available
are the SPARC polypropylene sling (American Medical Systems, Minneapolis,
Minnesota) and the TVT (tensionless vaginal tape, Ethicon, New Brunswick,
New Jersey). As with the TVT system, the SPARC has been suggested as
an outpatient procedure. We present the early complications of our first
140 slings, based on which we recommend that observation of all patients
overnight following the SPARC sling be considered.
-
Materials and Methods:
We retrospectively reviewed the charts of the first 140 patients who
received the SPARC polypropylene pubovaginal sling at our institution
to evaluate for early complications requiring intervention. Because
we wished to evaluate for occult bleeding, we checked the hematocrit
on postoperative day 1 in the last 57 patients regardless of blood loss
in the operating room.
-
Results:
A total of 6 patients required intervention in the early postoperative
period, including transfusion in 4 immediately postoperatively for retropubic
bleeding. One patient had presented with pelvic pain and vaginal bleeding
1 week postoperatively and was found to have a large retropubic hematoma
that required percutaneous drainage. The final patient was discharged
home on postoperative day 1 in stable condition but presented on postoperative
day 4 with drainage from a suprapubic incision. She had a perforation
through a loop of small bowel that required resection of a short segment
of the bowel and removal of the sling. The mean decrease in hematocrit
from preoperative to postoperative day 1 was 7.1% (range 1% to 14%)
despite a mean intraoperative blood loss in this group of 170 cc (range
less than 50 to 700 cc).
-
Conclusions:
We recommend caution with any patient who receives a sling that requires
passage of needles through the retropubic space, which can result in
occult retropubic bleeding, and dilation of the tract. While visceral
injury is exceedingly rare, it must be discussed as a possible risk
of the surgery. We continue to advocate SPARC as an excellent sling
option but we caution surgeons of the potential complications and urge
careful postoperative monitoring. We recommend that SPARC not routinely
be considered as an outpatient procedure.
- Editorial
Comment
The authors retrospectively reviewed the charts of 140 patients who
underwent a polypropylene suburethral pubovaginal sling using the SPARC
device. The patients’ charts were examined and notations were
made regarding the rate of post-operative hemorrhage with or without
transfusion as well as bowel injury. Based on the review the authors
recommend overnight observation after this surgery secondary to potential
complications and discourage its performance as an outpatient procedure.
This is another article from two outstanding urologists describing their
experience with the SPARC procedure and potential complications of same
(1). I feel the paper is excellent and warrants close reading by the
interested urologic surgeon. The only shortcoming of the paper I could
detect was that though the title claims this paper to be peri-operative
complications, the descriptions were fairly limited to that of bleeding
and potentially catastrophic bowel injury. Because of the wealth of
their experience, the authors have the potential to describe all the
complications associated with this specific procedure including dyspareunia,
tape erosions, urinary retention, persistent incontinence, as well as
anesthetic complications of pneumonia, throat/tracheal irritation etc.
The authors do describe the SPARC being potentially different from the
TVT operation secondary to the SPARC system using a “finger guided
delivery of the smaller needles from top to bottom”. This is somewhat
different from some of the previous descriptions of the operation, which
describe a shifting type maneuver of the needle once it perforates the
rectus fascia with the needle, then exiting the anterior vaginal epithelium
as opposed to a complete finger guided delivery that is done with a
formal opening of the urethral pelvic ligament. It may have been of
interest to hear the authors’ thoughts on whether the bowel injury
could have been avoided if the urethral pelvic ligament had been opened
and adhesion swept off the back of the pubic bone prior to the passage
of the suture ligature carriers. Nevertheless, the authors should be
commended in that the paper is excellent for its emphasis to the urologic
surgeon that just because one may do an operation as an outpatient,
it may not necessarily be the safest route of therapy and that in this
specific type of operation overnight stay may be warranted secondary
to potential post-operative hemorrhage or bowel injury.
Reference
1. Petrou SP: Editorial Comment. Management of vaginal erosion of polypropylene
mesh slings. Int Braz J Urol. 2003, 29: 280-1.
Dr.
Steven P. Petrou
Associate Professor of Urology
Mayo Medical School
Jacksonville, Florida, USA
The natural history of hydronephrosis after radical hysterectomy
with no intraoperatively recognizable injury to the ureter: a prospective
study
Paick SH, Oh SJ, Song YS, Kim HH
Departments of Urology and Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Seoul National
University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea
BJU Int. 2003; 92: 748-50
- Objective:
To
investigate, in a prospective study, the natural history of hydronephrosis
of the urinary tract after radical hysterectomy.
- Patients
and Methods: From December 1997 to March 2001, 34 patients
with localized cervical cancer underwent radical hysterectomy by one
gynaecologist, with no intraoperatively identifiable injury to the ureter.
Intravenous urography was used routinely before and at 2 and 4 weeks
after surgery. The degree of hydronephrosis was graded I - IV.
-
Results:
Urography before surgery showed no abnormal finding in any of the patients,
except in one with a unilateral duplex kidney. Hydronephrosis was found
in 10 units in the upper tract (grade II in eight, III in one and IV
in one) in seven patients (21%) 2 weeks after surgery (one right, three
left and three bilateral). All the ureteric narrowing was in the distal
ureter. The hydronephrosis disappeared in four units in three patients,
but became worse in two units in two patients with bilateral pathology
in the fourth week. At 3 months after surgery no hydronephrosis had
deteriorated and the hydronephrosis in all units had disappeared by
6 months. The presence of hydronephrosis was significantly correlated
with pathological stage and age (P < 0.05).
- Conclusion:
Hydronephrosis was detected after radical hysterectomy even with no
intraoperatively recognizable injury to the ureter, but in most the
hydronephrosis improved spontaneously and needed no ureteric stenting
or surgical intervention.
- Editorial
Comment
The authors perform a prospective study on the natural history of hydronephrosis
after radical hysterectomy. The population was limited to patients who
had undergone radical hysterectomy by a single gynecologist with no
intraoperative injury to the ureter. The patients were followed by radiographic
imaging using intravenous urography preoperatively then again at 2 and
4 weeks postoperatively. Findings included the presence of hydronephrosis
in 10 renal units out of the 34 patients who were included in the study.
There was no serial increase in any noted hydronephrosis at the 3 month
postoperative check-up and there was radiographic resolution all affected
kidneys by 6 months. The value of this study lies in its assisting the
urologist in understanding the natural history of incidental hydronephrosis
after hysterectomy. Many times the consulting urologist noting this
radiographic finding must make the diagnostic and clinical decision
to perform ureteric stenting versus percutaneous nephrostomy tube or
allow for watchful waiting. This study emboldens those urologists who
wish to follow an asymptomatic patient conservatively. The authors should
be commended on their study. The paper’s value may have been potentially
increased if a comment could have been made on whether the patients
had undergone cystourethroscopy after intravenous indigo carmine injection
during the operation (1) to delineate ureteral patency; in addition,
a description of the postoperative urinalysis and serum creatinine in
all patients postoperatively with special emphasis on the patients with
abnormal radiographic findings and a brief commentary on the patient’s
symptoms and clinical examination would have been enlightening. One
wonders based on this study, what the rate of incidental and clinically
significant post operative hydronephrosis would be in patients with
patent ureters checked intraoperatively with intravenous indigo carmine.
Reference
1. Pettit PD, Petrou SP: The value of cystoscopy in major vaginal surgery.
Obst Gynecol. 1994; 84: 318-20.
Dr.
Steven P. Petrou
Associate Professor of Urology
Mayo Medical School
Jacksonville, Florida, USA
PEDIATRIC UROLOGY
One
hundred percent patient and kidney allograft survival with simultaneous
liver and kidney transplantation in infants with primary hyperoxaluria:
a single-center experience
Millan MT, Berquist WE, So SK, Sarwal MM, Wayman KI, Cox KL, Filler G,
Salvatierra O Jr, Esquivel CO
Stanford University School of Medicine, Palo Alto, CA 94304, USA
Transplantation 2003; 76: 1458-63
-
Background:
Combined liver-kidney transplantation is the definitive treatment for
end-stage renal disease caused by primary hyperoxaluria type I (PH1).
The infantile form is characterized by renal failure early in life,
advanced systemic oxalosis, and a formidable mortality rate. Although
others have reported on overall results of transplantation for PH1 covering
a wide age spectrum, none has specifically addressed the high-risk infantile
form of the disease.
-
Methods:
Six infants with PH1 underwent simultaneous liver-kidney transplantation
at our center between May 1994 and August 1998. Diagnosis was made at
5.2 +/- 3.3 months of age, they were on dialysis for 11.8 +/- 2.3 months,
and they underwent transplantation at 14.8 +/- 3.0 months of age when
they weighed 10.6 +/- 1.7 kg.
-
Results:
At a mean follow-up of 6.4 +/- 1.7 years (range, 3.9 - 8.1 years), we
report 100% patient and kidney allograft survival. There were no cases
of acute tubular necrosis. Long-term kidney allograft function remained
stable in all patients, with serum creatinine values of less than 1.1
mg/dL and a mean creatinine clearance of 99 mL/min/1.73 m2 at follow-up.
Those who received combined hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis pretransplant
had lower posttransplant urinary oxalate values than those receiving
peritoneal dialysis alone. There was improvement in growth and psychomotor
and mental developmental scores after transplantation.
- Conclusions:
Combined liver-kidney transplantation for the infantile presentation
of PH1 is associated with excellent outcome when the approach includes
early diagnosis and early combined transplantation, aggressive pretransplant
dialysis, and avoidance of posttransplant renal dysfunction.
- Editorial
Comment
The authors report their experience with a rare but physiologically
important disease. Primary hyperoxaluria is a severe, life-threatening
disease that results in systemic oxalosis and early renal failure. Treatment
of the neonatal renal failure has involved various regimens of “hyperdialysis”
along with renal transplantation, as the total body oxalate stores are
so high that immediately after successful renal transplantation, severe
hyperoxaluria results. Because the enzyme deficiency responsible for
the condition is in the liver primarily, renal transplantation alone
does not solve the basic problem long-term. Hence, some have advocated
combined liver and kidney transplantation, that, when combined with
a regimen of “hyperdialysis” preoperatively should be curative.
The authors present their experience with 6 cases in which the infants
underwent liver-kidney transplant at a mean age of 15 months. All patients
have survived with good renal function at a mean follow-up of 6.4 years.
Though this approach is still experimental, the authors demonstrate
a remarkable result in children who otherwise would have an extremely
high mortality.
Dr.
Barry A. Kogan
Chief and Professor of Urology and Pediatrics
Albany Medical College
Albany, New York, USA
Long-term outcome of laparoscopically managed nonpalpable testes
Radmayr C, Oswald J, Schwentner C, Neururer R, Peschel R, Bartsch G
Department of Pediatric Urology, University of Innsbruck, Austria
J Urol. 2003; 170: 2409-11
-
Purpose:
We evaluated laparoscopic diagnostic findings in 108 impalpable testes,
and analyzed the success rate and long-term outcome of either direct
laparoscopic orchiopexy or the 2-stage Fowler-Stephens procedure.
- Materials
and Methods: A total of 84 children with 108 impalpable testes
and a mean age of 1.9 years underwent laparoscopy between 1992 and September
2000. Long-term outcome with regard to viability and location of the
testes was evaluated.
- Results:
Of the 108 testes 72 were located intra-abdominally, of which 28 were
managed by direct laparoscopic orchiopexy, 29 were managed by a 2-stage
laparoscopic Fowler-Stephens procedure and 15 were vanishing. The remaining
36 testes were inguinally located during exploration and orchiopexy,
except for 5 vanishing testes. In all cases the operation proceeded
as planned. After a mean followup of 6.2 years all laparoscopically
managed testicles were in a normal scrotal position with normal perfusion
as revealed by color flow Doppler sonography. Two testicles became atrophic
after a 2-stage Fowler-Stephens procedure. Morbidity was low in all
children.
- Conclusions:
The laparoscopic approach allows not only diagnosis, but also adequate
therapy regardless of whether direct orchiopexy or a 2-stage procedure
is performed. Our long-term results clearly demonstrate that even in
the patients undergoing the 2-stage procedure the laparoscopic approach
is safe and efficient, and leads to excellent results concerning viability
of the affected testicles. Progress and experience gained during recent
years are encouraging in continuing laparoscopic procedures in children.
- Editorial
Comment
The management of nonpalpable testes has changed dramatically in the
past 10 years. Currently in most centers, diagnostic laparoscopy is
the procedure of choice. This has been demonstrated clearly to be the
procedure of choice for localization of high testes. In some cases,
the diagnosis of “vanishing” testes can be made and this
is sufficient to avoid further operative intervention. In others the
visualization of the exact position of the testis will determine the
operative plan. In some cases an inguinal approach is sufficient, but
in others an abdominal approach is needed. Based on advances in laparoscopic
techniques, most intraabdominal testes can be brought down with using
laparoscopic dissection, as either a single- or a two-staged procedure.
However the literature is short on long-term results of these procedures.
The authors report their experience with laparoscopic management of
84 children with 108 nonpalpable testes. Ultimately 28 underwent a single-stage
laparoscopic orchiopexy and 29 underwent a 2-stage laparoscopic Fowler-Stephens
type of orchiopexy. The results at a mean follow-up of 6.2 years are
reported. Of the children who underwent the single-stage procedures,
all had testes in a normal scrotal position with normal perfusion by
Doppler ultrasound. Of those undergoing the two-stage procedure, two
had atrophic testes. Although these results are less good, these procedures
were, of course, done in a more difficult population with testes that
were no doubt higher than the others were. Overall the surgical results
are excellent and they were achieved with a minimum of morbidity.
On the other hand, it must be said that the authors use “long-term”
loosely. For example, what will the adult testicular size be? Will the
epididymis in these patients allow normal sperm development and transport?
Will the vas function normally? What will the sperm counts/fertility
be? What will the incidence of neoplasia be? What we need in pediatric
urology are data that are truly “long-term”.
Dr.
Barry A. Kogan
Chief and Professor of Urology and Pediatrics
Albany Medical College
Albany, New York, USA |