STONE
DISEASE
A
prospective randomized comparison of type of nephrostomy drainage following
percutaneous nephrostolithotomy: large bore versus small bore versus tubeless
Desai MR, Kukreja RA, Desai MM, Mhaskar SS, Wani KA, Patel SH, Bapat SD
Department of Urology, Muljibhai Patel Urological Hospital, Nadiad, India
J Urol. 2004; 172: 565-7
-
Purpose:
We compared postoperative outcomes among tubeless, conventional large
bore nephrostomy drainage and small bore nephrostomy drainage following
percutaneous nephrostolithotomy (PCNL) in a prospective randomized fashion.
-
Materials and Methods:
Between January and June 2001, 30 patients undergoing PCNL were randomized
to receive conventional large bore (20Fr) nephrostomy drainage (group
1, 10 patients), small bore (9Fr) nephrostomy drainage (group 2, 10
patients) or no nephrostomy drainage (group 3, 10 patients). Inclusion
criteria included a single subcostal tract, uncomplicated procedure,
normal preoperative renal function and complete stone clearance. Factors
compared among the 3 groups were postoperative analgesia requirement,
urinary extravasation, duration of hematuria, duration of urinary leak,
decrease in hematocrit and hospital stay.
-
Results:
The postoperative analgesic requirement was significantly higher in
group 1 (217 mg) compared to groups 2 (140 mg, p <0.05) and 3 (87.5
mg, p <0.0001). Patients in group 3 had a significantly shorter duration
(4.8 hours) of urinary leak through the percutaneous renal tract compared
to patients in groups 1 (21.4 hours, p <0.05) and 2 (13.2 hours,
p <0.05). Hospital stay was significantly shorter in group 3 (3.4
days) compared to groups 1 (4.4 days, p <0.05) and 2 (4.3 days, p
<0.05). All 3 groups were similar in terms of operative time, duration
of hematuria and decrease in hematocrit. Postoperative ultrasound did
not reveal significant urinary extravasation in any case.
-
Conclusions:
Tubeless PCNL is associated with the least postoperative pain, urinary
leakage and hospital stay. Small bore nephrostomy drainage may be a
reasonable option in patients in whom the incidence of stent dysuria
is likely to be higher.
- Editorial
Comment
In an effort to reduce the morbidity of percutaneous nephrostolithotomy
(PCNL), making it more competitive with ureteroscopy and SWL for the
management of renal calculi, some practitioners have reduced the size
of the post-PCNL nephrostomy tube or eliminated the tube altogether.
Although tubeless PCNL has clear demonstrable advantages over traditional
large bore, nephrostomy tubes with regard to hospital stay and pain
medication requirements, the advantages of a small caliber nephrostomy
tube have been less clear-cut in published trials. However, the use
of a small caliber tube has the advantage of allowing reentry into the
collecting system if needed, but potentially incurs less discomfort
postoperatively.
Desai and colleagues performed a prospective, randomized trial comparing
the three approaches to post-PCNL tube management in 30 patients undergoing
uncomplicated PCNL requiring a single, subcostal percutaneous access.
Although the three groups were comparable with regard to postoperative
complications, the tubeless group required significantly less pain medication
post-PCNL, the nephrostomy tract sealed quickest and hospital stay was
shortest. However, the small caliber tube group had less pain and shorter
duration of urine leakage compared with the than the large caliber group.
Although the study groups were small and the study perhaps underpowered
to detect small differences between the groups, there clearly appeared
to be an advantage to no nephrostomy tube or a small nephrostomy tube.
The authors offered an algorithm for tube selection that is provides
a reasonable approach for tube selection post-operatively. In cases
in which a stone free status is fairly certain (for example, simple
“pluck-and-run” procedures) after a relatively simple, bloodless
procedure, the tubeless approach is a good option. For cases in which
the stone is complex, the stone burden large or the procedure complicated
or bloody, a large bore nephrostomy tube is advisable. For other procedures
that are uncomplicated and not associated with a large blood loss (the
majority of procedures), a small caliber nephrostomy tube is likely
to reduce patient discomfort but does not preclude second look flexible
nephroscopy in the event residual stones are detected.
Dr.
Margaret S. Pearle
Associate Professor of Urology
University of Texas Southwestern Med Ctr
Dallas, Texas, USA
The
effect of treatment strategy on stone comminution efficiency in shock
wave lithotripsy
Zhou Y, Cocks FH, Preminger GM, Zhong P
Department of Mechanical Engineering and Materials Science, Duke University,
Durham, North Carolina, USA
J Urol. 2004; 172: 349-54
-
Purpose:
The comminution of kidney stones in shock wave lithotripsy (SWL) is
a dose dependent process caused primarily by the combination of 2 fundamental
mechanisms, namely stress waves and cavitation. The effect of treatment
strategy with emphasis on enhancing the effect of stress waves or cavitation
on stone comminution in SWL was investigated. Because vascular injury
in SWL is also dose dependent, optimization of the treatment strategy
may produce improved stone comminution with decreased tissue injury
in SWL.
- Materials
and Methods: Using an in vitro experiment system that mimics
stone fragmentation in the renal pelvis spherical BegoStone (Bego USA,
Smithfield, Rhode Island) phantoms (diameter 10 mm) were exposed to
1,500 shocks at a pulse repetition rate of 1 Hz in an unmodified HM-3
lithotripter (Dornier Medical Systems, Kennesaw, Georgia). The 3 treatment
strategies used were increasing output voltage from 18 to 20 and then
to 22 kV every 500 shocks with emphasis on enhancing the effect of cavitation
on medium fragments (2 to 4 mm) at the final treatment stage, decreasing
output voltage from 22 to 20 and then to 18 kV every 500 shocks with
emphasis on enhancing the effect of stress waves on large fragments
(greater than 4 mm) at the initial treatment stage and maintaining a
constant output voltage at 20 kV, as typically used in SWL procedures.
Following shock wave exposure the size distribution of fragments was
determined by the sequential sieving method. In addition, pressure waveforms
at lithotripter focus (F2) produced at different output settings were
measured using a fiber optic probe hydrophone.
-
Results:
The rate of stone comminution in SWL varied significantly in a dose
dependent manner depending on the treatment strategies used. Specifically
the comminution efficiencies produced by the 3 strategies after the
initial 500 shocks were 30.7%, 59% and 41.9%, respectively. After 1,000
shocks the corresponding comminution efficiencies became similar (60.2%,
68.1% and 66.4%, respectively) with no statistically significant differences
(p = 0.08). After 1,500 shocks, the final comminution efficiency produced
by the first strategy was 88.7%, which was better than the corresponding
values of 81.2% and 83.5%, respectively, for the other 2 strategies.
The difference between the final comminution efficiency of the first
and second strategies was statistically significant (p = 0.005).
-
Conclusions:
Progressive increase in lithotripter output voltage can produce the
best overall stone comminution in vitro.
-
Editorial Comment
Surprisingly little progress has occurred in lithotripter technology
over the last 2 decades, and even less has translated into improved
clinical success. However, recent efforts have been underway to not
only improve technological aspects of lithotripters but to optimize
treatment parameters to improve the efficiency and success of stone
fragmentation.
Zhou and colleagues compared the efficiency of in vitro fragmentation
of stone phantoms with a Dornier HM3 lithotripter using 3 different
strategies for administering output voltage: stepwise increase in voltage,
stepwise decrease in voltage and constant voltage, with all strategies
delivering approximately the same overall acoustic dose. Although initially,
fragmentation efficiency correlated with shock wave dosage, ultimately
comminution efficiency was greatest when output voltage was increased
in a stepwise fashion compared with a strategy of decreasing or constant
voltage. These finding are consistent with 2 synergistic processes of
stone fragmentation, one based on stress waves that are thought to be
pivotal in initial stone fragmentation, and one based on cavitation
that is responsible for completion of fragmentation to small, passable
pieces.
These findings have yet to be validated in an animal model or in the
clinical realm; however, they suggest that a strategy of a stepwise
incremental increase in shock wave voltage output may provide for more
effective stone fragmentation while potentially reducing tissue injury.
This is encouraging news; perhaps by slowing the rate of delivery of
shock waves as suggested by a recent randomized trial and incrementally
increasing the output voltage during SWL, stone free rates may be improved
without further risking tissue injury and without the need for new lithotripter
technology.
Dr.
Margaret S. Pearle
Associate Professor of Urology
University of Texas Southwestern Med Ctr
Dallas, Texas, USA
ENDOUROLOGY & LAPAROSCOPY
Clinical
utility of dual active deflection flexible ureteroscope during upper tract
ureteropyeloscopy
Ankem MK, Lowry PS, Slovick RW, del Rio AM, Nakada SY
From the Division of Urology, Department of Surgery, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Medical School, Madison, Wisconsin, USA; Division of Urology, Scott &
White Memorial Hospital, Texas A&M University College of Medicine,
Temple, Texas, USA
Urology. 2004; 64: 430-4
-
Objectives:
To evaluate the clinical utility of a dual active deflection ACMI DUR-8
Elite ureteroscope in a referral endourology practice.
- Methods:
Retrospective chart review was performed on 54 consecutive patients
who underwent flexible ureteroscopy by a single surgeon (S.Y.N.) from
February to July 2003. Cases in which standard flexible ureteroscopes
alone could complete the procedure, cases in which standard flexible
ureteroscopy could not complete the procedure and the DUR-8 Elite ureteroscope
did, and cases in which both ureteroscopes failed to complete the procedure
were analyzed.
-
Results:
A total of 54 procedures were performed on 37 patients. Three cases
were not analyzed because they were distal ureter procedures. Of the
remaining 51 procedures, 6 were removed from analysis because they were
second-look procedures. When classified by diagnosis, 27 patients had
stones (79.4%), 5 had cancer (14.7%), and 1 had hematuria (2.9%). The
global success rate was 91.1%. The average use rate of the DUR-8 was
28.9%, and the success rate using the DUR-8 Elite was 69.2% in those
cases in which it was necessary. Of the 13 cases in which the DUR-8
was used, 61.5% were for lower pole pathologic findings. The DUR Elite
use and success rate in the lower pole was 57.1% and 75%, respectively.
A statistically significant association was found between the diagnosis
and procedure location (P = 0.00128).
-
Conclusions:
Our preliminary data indicate that the dual deflecting DUR-8 Elite ureteroscope
may be helpful in cases in which the single deflection flexible instruments
fail to access and treat upper urinary tract pathologic findings.
- Editorial
Comment
The second actively flexible portion of the ureteroscope used by the
authors provides an additional 170 degrees of flexion in one direction.
The authors clearly demonstrate the utility of this device in their
hands. In almost 1/3 of cases, the authors had sub-optimal access with
the standard (single actively flexible joint) ureteroscope, and the
dual active deflection ACMI DUR-8 Elite ureteroscope was used. About
half of the uses of the DUR-8 were for inability to access a calyx (usually
lower pole), and about half were because even the 200 micron laser fiber
restricted flexion of the standard ureteroscope and the extra flexion
of the DUR-8 was needed. Overall, the DUR-8 was successful 2/3 of the
time it was used. We have trialed the DUR-8 and other dual active deflection
ureteroscopes at our institution but have not yet made a purchase. We
have found that failure to access a calyx is uncommon with a good-condition
single active deflection ureteroscope and patience. When access is not
possible, stones can generally be moved with a nitinol tipless basket
(which can get to a stone even when it can barely be seen through the
ureteroscope). Moreover, with use of this stone displacement technique,
stones in a location that push the limits of flexibility with the 200-micron
laser fiber can be moved and addressed more effectively elsewhere. As
such, we have less of a use for a dual active deflection ureteroscope
than these authors do. That being said, in cases of tumor or large stones,
where the lesions cannot be moved, these scopes would undoubtedly be
of use. They probably do merit a place in the armamentarium of a busy
endourologist.
Dr.
J. Stuart Wolf Jr.
Associate Professor of Urology
University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA
Laparoscopic versus open partial nephrectomy
Beasley KA, Al Omar M, Shaikh A, Bochinski D, Khakhar A, Izawa JI, Welch
RO, Chin JL, Kapoor A, Luke PP
From the Division of Urology, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario,
Canada; Department of Decision Support, London Health Sciences Centre,
London, Ontario, Canada; Division of Urology, McMaster University, Hamilton,
Ontario, Canada
Urology. 2004; 64: 458-61
-
Objectives: To
compare, retrospectively, the results of laparoscopic partial nephrectomy
(LPN) to open partial nephrectomy (OPN) using a tumor size-matched cohort
of patients. Limited data are available comparing LPN to OPN in the
treatment of small renal tumors.
- Methods:
Between September 2000 and September 2003, 27 LPNs and 22 OPNs were
performed to treat renal masses less than 4 cm. Patient demographics
and tumor location and size (2.4 ± 1.0 cm versus 2.9 ±
0.9 cm, respectively; P = not statistically significant) were similar
between the LPN and OPN groups.
-
Results:
Although the mean operative time was longer in the LPN than in the OPN
group (210 ± 76 minutes versus 144 ± 24 minutes; P <0.001),
the blood loss was comparable between the two groups (250 ± 250
mL versus 334 ± 343 mL; P = not statistically significant). No
blood transfusions were performed in either group. The hospital stay
was significantly reduced after LPN compared with after OPN (2.9 ±
1.5 days versus 6.4 ± 1.8 days; P <0.0002), and the postoperative
parenteral narcotic requirements were lower in the LPN group (mean morphine
equivalent 43 ± 62 mg versus 187 ± 71 mg; P <0.02).
Three complications occurred in each group. With LPN, no patient had
positive margins or tumor recurrence. Also, direct financial analysis
demonstrated lower total hospital costs after LPN ($4839 ± $1551
versus $6297 ± $2972; P <0.05).
- Conclusions:
LPN confers several benefits over OPN concerning patient convalescence
and costs, despite prolonged resection times at our current phase of
the learning curve. Long-term results on cancer control in patients
treated with LPN continue to be assessed.
- Editorial
Comment
Laparoscopic nephron sparing surgery is here to stay! Although other
comparative studies have been published, this study it notable for the
remarkable similarity between the open and laparoscopic groups. The
data suggest that the safety and efficacy of the laparoscopic procedure
is equivalent to that of open surgery, with improved convalescence and
reduced cost. In addition, the authors are not part of the original
group that started performing this procedure in the mid-to-late 1990’s.
They are part of the second wave of skilled laparoscopic surgeons who
have better training, have learned from the efforts of the pioneers,
and have successfully incorporate laparoscopy into routine oncologic
practice. At large centers with advanced laparoscopy, laparascopic partial
nephrectomy is now the standard approach to all but the most central
of small renal masses. The enthusiasm for the procedure must not overcome
good surgical practice, however. The difficulty of laparascopic partial
nephrectomy increases dramatically as tumors are deeper and more central.
Each surgeon must establish individual “comfort zones” with
the lesion that he or she can tackle laparoscopically. In the early
experience at our own institution, we overestimated our technique after
a series of challenging but successful cases - only to have some major
hemorrhagic complications (the complication that typically rewards the
overconfident surgeon in this procedure). We backed off, altered our
technique, slowly advanced again, and are now routinely performing laparascopic
partial nephrectomies that would have failed with our technique of only
a year ago. Renal hilar clamping and laparoscopic suturing are, despite
great efforts to simplify the technique, still required for deep resections
with the current technology. There is great hope that future advances
will reduce the technical requirements, and risk, of laparascopic partial
nephrectomy.
Dr.
J. Stuart Wolf Jr.
Associate Professor of Urology
University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA
IMAGING
Comparison
of 3 different methods of anesthesia before transrectal prostate biopsy:
a prospective randomized trial
Öbek C , Özkan B, Tunc B, Can G, Yalcin V, Solok V
Departments of Urology and Public Health (GC), University of Istanbul,
Cerrahpasa School of Medicine, Istanbul
J Urol. 2004; 172: 502-5
- Purpose:
Periprostatic nerve block (PNB) is the most common anesthesia technique
used before prostate biopsy. However, needle punctures for anesthetic
infiltration may be painful and cause higher infectious complications.
We assessed whether addition of rectal lidocaine gel would improve its
efficacy. We also investigated the efficacy and safety of tramadol,
a codeine derivative, as a noninvasive method.
-
Materials and Methods:
A total of 300 patients who underwent prostate biopsies were randomized
into 4 groups of controls, PNB, perianal/intrarectal lidocaine gel plus
PNB and tramadol. Pain was assessed with a numeric analog scale.
-
Results:
Each group consisted of 75 patients, and there was a statistically significant
difference among pain scores (p = 0.001). Mean pain scores were 4.63
for controls, 2.57 for PNB, 2.03 for infiltration plus gel group and
3.11 for tramadol. Pain and discomfort were least in PNB plus gel arm.
The difference of pain score between PNB alone and tramadol group did
not reach statistical significance. Infectious complications were higher
in the combination group, whereas there were no complications with tramadol.
-
Conclusions:
Any form of analgesia/anesthesia was superior to none. The combination
of PNB plus gel provided significantly better analgesia compared to
PNB alone or tramadol. If this can be duplicated in other trials, the
combination may be accepted as the new gold standard of anesthesia for
prostate biopsy. The efficacy of tramadol was similar to that of PNB,
and was free of complications. Therefore, tramadol may have a role before
prostate biopsy, which needs to be explored.
- Editorial
Comment
Several methods with different approaches have been used in the recent
years in order to obtain analgesia/anesthesia for transrectal ultrasound
guided biopsy of the prostate. The authors compared in a prospective
randomized trial, three different methods of anesthesia before transrectal
prostate biopsy and they achieved significantly better analgesia with
the combination of periprostatic nerve block and intrarectal injection
of lidocaine gel. They also proposed the use of intravenous infusion
of tramadol as an additional procedure for improvement of patient tolerance
and comfort. If there is any doubt about the benefit of using local
anesthesia for prostatic biopsy this article definitely cleared this
out. At our institution periprostatic lidocaine injection has been performed
since April 2000. Differently from the method showed in this article
where periprostatic nerve block was performed by infiltrating 2.5 cc
of 2% lidocaine to the neurovascular bundle at the base of the prostate
, we inject 2.5 cc of lidocaine on each side of the prostate apex. This
approach has been used due the fact that in our opinion , patient discomfort
during biopsy without anesthesia is higher when the prostate apex is
biopsied in comparison with the prostate base(1). Following the same
principles pointed out by the authors, 500 mg of paracetamol (acetaminophen;
nonopiate, nonsalicylate analgesic) is orally administered, 30 minutes
before the procedure. Although less potent than tramadol, paracetamol
is generally well tolerated and do not have adverse events such as nausea
and vomiting which can occur with tramadol in some patients particularly
in older ones.This article clearly shows that the association of some
type of periprostatic nerve block with intrarectal injection of lidocaine
gel is a much better method.Based on their results we decided to include
the use of intrarectal injection of lidocaine gel in our protocol.
Reference
1. Schostak M, Christoph F, Muller M, Heicappell R, Goessl G, Staehler
M, Miller K: Optimizing local anesthesia during 10-core biopsy of the
prostate. Urology. 2002; 60: 253-7.
Dr.
Adilson Prando
Chief, Department of Radiology
Vera Cruz Hospital
Campinas, São Paulo, Brazil
Coronal
imaging to assess urinary tract stone size
Nadler RB, Stern JA, Kimm S, Hoff F, Rademaker AW
Department of Urology, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine,
Chicago, Illinois, USA
J Urol. 2004: 172: 962-4
- Purpose:
Urinary tract stones are typically measured using axial images from
computerized tomography (CT). Such images provide a precise measurement
of stone length and width. However, cephalocaudad dimensions can be
difficult to determine from axial images. Coronal reconstructions, which
can more accurately measure cephalocaudad dimensions, are seldom used
to measure stones. We determined if coronal reconstructions could aid
in more precisely determining stone size.
-
Materials and Methods:
CT in patients who had undergone CT to evaluate urolithiasis at our
institution during the 9-month period of January 2001 to September 2001
were reviewed. Length and width were measured using axial images, and
cephalocaudad length and width were measured using coronal reconstructions.
Cephalocaudad length was also estimated from axial images. Total area
was calculated from axial and coronal reconstructions. The paired t
test was used to assess statistical significance.
-
Results:
The CT images of 102 patients with a total of 151 stones had undergone
coronal reconstructions and, thus, were included in the study. Mean
area in the axial and coronal reconstruction groups was 22.23 and 31.29
mm3, respectively. Mean greatest axial dimension (length or width) was
4.87 mm and mean greatest coronal dimension (cephalocaudad length) was
6.51 mm. Cephalocaudad length estimated from axial images was 8.8 mm.
Differences for all 3 of these comparisons (axial vs. coronal area,
greatest axial vs. coronal dimension and estimated vs. actual cephalocaudad
length) proved to be statistically significant (p <0.0001).
-
Conclusions: While
urinary tract stones have typically been measured using axial images,
coronal images provide a different impression of stone size. These data
demonstrate that examining only axial images provides an inaccurate
measure of stone size. We suggest that coronal images should also be
used to measure more accurately stone size, which is critical for clinical
decision making.
- Editorial
Comment
The authors describe the impact on the estimation of the size of ureteral
stone when this measurement is done also on coronal images. This is
an important contribution since several studies has shown the accuracy
of non-enhanced CT estimation of stone size using only the transverse
plane (axial images). Size measurement and location of the stone in
the ureter, are the most important determinants of therapy. The authors
has shown that size measurement is precisely evaluated by non-enhanced
CT, particularly when the coronal images are additionally used for obtaining
an accurate volumetric measurement of the urinary calculi (greatest
axial and craniocaudal length). An accurate determination of the size
of the stone in the ureter is important since about 90% of stones 1
mm in diameter does pass, but less than 50% of stones larger than 7
mm pass. Urinary calculi located in the upper ureter and measuring 5
mm or more, usually do not pass spontaneously, whereas distal stones
even if fairly large most often do pass. In general, stones larger than
6 mm commonly require intervention. In conclusion, radiologist should
use both planes (axial and coronal) in order to obtain adequate measurement
of stone size.
Dr.
Adilson Prando
Chief, Department of Radiology
Vera Cruz Hospital
Campinas, São Paulo, Brazil
UROGENITAL
TRAUMA
Evaluation
and management of renal injuries: consensus statement of the renal
trauma subcommittee.
Santucci RA, Wessells H, Bartsch G, Descotes J, Heyns CF, McAninch JW,
Nash P,
Schmidlin F
BJU Int. 2004; 93: 937-54
-
Objective:
To determine the optimal evaluation and management of renal injuries
by review of the world’s English-language literature on the subject.
-
Methods:
A consensus conference convened by the World Health Organization and
the Societe Internationale d’Urologie met to critically review
reports of the diagnosis and treatment of renal trauma. The English-language
literature about renal trauma was identified using Medline, and additional
cited works not detected in the initial search obtained. Evidence-based
recommendations for the diagnosis and management of renal trauma were
made with reference to a five-point scale.
-
Results:
There were many Level 3 and 4 citations, few Level 2, and one Level
1 which supported clinical practice patterns. Findings of nearly 200
reviewed citations are summarized.
-
Conclusions:
Published reports on renal trauma still rely heavily on expert opinion
and single-institution retrospective case series. Prospective trials
of the most significant issues, when possible, might improve the quality
of evidence that dictates the behaviour of practitioners.
- Editorial
Comment
Consensus conferences, using the so called “Cochrane Review Method”
are becoming increasingly common, and may be useful to summarize intricate
data sets such as how to mange complex genitourinary trauma. The technique
is robust for several reasons. First, an attempt to read “every”
published paper on the subject is made. Secondly, the manuscripts are
carefully graded by “level of evidence” (Level 1=randomized
trials; 2=prospective studies; 3=retrospective studies, 4=case series/case
reports, 5=expert opinion). Third, consensus conference members are
chosen with proven expertise in the field, all in order to maximize
the value of the review. This particular review was sponsored by the
World Health Organization (WHO) and was undertaken by the Societé
Internationale d’Urologie (SIU), and represents thousands of hours
of work.
In this review, over 1400 articles on the subject of renal injury were
identified, although only 182 were ultimately cited in this review.
Although the findings of this 14,000 word review are too numerous to
discuss in detail here, I encourage readers who wish to understand the
most modern and up to date treatment of renal injuries to obtain and
read it. Interestingly, there were only a few prospective studies and
only 1 randomized trial in existence across the whole trauma series.
Clearly, the future of research in the field of genitourinary trauma
will be best served by conducting prospective and perhaps even randomized
studies into those questions most urgently requiring answers.
Dr. Richard A. Santucci
Assistant Professor of Urology
Wayne State University
Detroit, Michigan, USA
Pediatric renal injuries: management guidelines from a 25-year experience
Buckley JC, McAninch JW
Department of Urology, University of California School of Medicine and
Urology
Service, San Francisco General Hospital, USA.
J Urol. 2004; 172: 687-90
- Purpose:
We defined the mechanism and cause of pediatric renal trauma, and developed
guidelines for management based on the outcome analysis of operative
vs nonoperative management.
-
Materials and Methods: We
retrospectively reviewed 374 pediatric renal injuries at San Francisco
General Hospital, comparing operative vs nonoperative management based
on clinical presentation, type of renal injury, hemodynamic stability,
associated injuries and the results of radiographic imaging.
-
Results:
Blunt trauma accounted for 89% of pediatric renal trauma with a renal
exploration rate of less than 2%. Penetrating trauma represented the
remaining 11% with a renal exploration rate of 76%. Of grade IV renal
injuries 41% were successfully managed nonoperatively based on computerized
tomography and staging in hemodynamically stable children. Our overall
renal salvage rate was greater than 99%.
-
Conclusions: Pediatric
renal trauma is often minor and observation poses no significant danger
to the child. In serious pediatric renal injuries early detection and
staging based on clinical presentation and computerized tomography are
critical for determining operative vs nonoperative management. Regardless
of the type of management the standard of care is renal preservation
(less than 1% nephrectomy rate in this series).
- Editorial
Comment
This series, from the most reliable American center of excellence in
GU trauma surgery, is one of the largest pediatric series ever published.
The lessons from this series are clear:
1. Most (96%) blunt pediatric renal injuries of low severity (Grades
I-III).
2. Overall, 41% of Grade IV injuries were managed nonoperatively (mostly
blunt).
Even some (24%) penetrating renal injuries were treated nonoperatively.
3. Few patients (1/37 explored, overall 1/374 patients seen) patients
required a nephrectomy.
4. Worsening urinary extravasation required stent placement uncommonly—in
only 1 case.
Large and authoritative series such as this lend further support for
an initial nonoperative approach to most hemodynamically stable renal
injuries, even in children. Patients with suspected Grade V vascular
injuries (avulsion of the hilar vessels, and those that acutely require
more than 3 units of blood, are the only absolute indications for surgery.
Dr.
Richard A. Santucci
Assistant Professor of Urology
Wayne State University
Detroit, Michigan, USA
PATHOLOGY
Bladder
neck invasion is an independent predictor of prostate-specific antigen
recurrence
Poulos CK, Koch MO, Eble JN, Daggy JK, Cheng L
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Indiana University School
of Medicine, Indianapolis, USA
Cancer. 2004; 101: 1563-8
-
Background:
The 1997 TNM staging system for prostatic carcinoma and the 2002 revision
thereof classified prostatic carcinoma with bladder neck involvement
classified as pT4 disease. This classification is based on the belief
that tumors that invade surrounding structures are more aggressive and
warrant higher staging than tumors that do not invade surrounding structures.
Recent reports in the literature suggested that microscopic involvement
of the bladder neck does not carry independent prognostic significance.
Therefore, resection specimens with bladder neck involvement should
not be classified as pT4. The current study prospectively examined the
prognostic significance of bladder neck involvement by prostatic carcinoma.
-
Methods:
The authors analyzed the totally embedded and whole-mounted radical
prostatectomy specimens from 364 consecutive patients. The mean patient
age was 66 years (range, 41-77 years). The bladder neck, which had been
coned from the specimen, was cut in a perpendicular fashion. Involvement
of the bladder neck was defined as the presence of neoplastic cells
within the smooth muscle bundles of the coned bladder neck. The data
were prospectively collected. Bladder neck involvement was analyzed
in relation to age, preoperative prostate-specific antigen (PSA) level,
prostate weight, Gleason score, final pathologic classification, tumor
volume, surgical margin status, the presence of high-grade prostate
intraepithelial neoplasm, multifocality, seminal vesicle invasion, extraprostatic
extension, perineural invasion, and PSA recurrence.
-
Results:
Bladder neck involvement was found in 22 (6%) of 364 patients. Univariate
results indicated that bladder neck involvement versus no bladder neck
involvement was significantly associated with preoperative PSA (P <
0.001), higher pathologic classification (P < 0.001), larger tumor
volume (P < 0.001), extraprostatic extension (P < 0.001), positive
surgical margins (P < 0.001), and PSA recurrence (P = 0.003). In
a multivariate logistic regression model controlling for pathologic
classification, Gleason score, and surgical margin status, bladder neck
involvement was an independent predictor of PSA recurrence (P = 0.04).
The adjusted odds ratio for bladder neck involvement was 3.3 (95% confidence
interval, 1.04-10.03).
- Conclusions:
In the current study, bladder neck involvement was an independent predictor
of early PSA recurrence. The data demonstrated the importance of continued
assessment of bladder neck invasion and supported the placement of tumors
with bladder neck involvement in a stage that recognizes the prognostic
implications of such involvement.
- Editorial
Comment
Recent studies have questioned the high risk for disease recurrence
in cases of bladder neck involvement by the prostate cancer (pT4 disease)
(1-4). The risk of recurrence conferred with bladder neck invasion appears
not to be different from that with extraprostatic extension (pT3a) or
seminal vesical invasion (pT3b).
In a recent study based on patients submitted to radical prostatectomy
at our institution (4), we found that bladder neck involvement correlates
with pathologic unfavorable findings on radical prostatectomy specimens
as well as to preoperative PSA levels. However, the PSA-recurrence risk
associated with bladder neck involvement (pT4) was similar to extraprostatic
extension (pT3a) and substantially lower than seminal vesicle invasion
(pT3b). Our findings favor a need for downstaging of bladder neck involvement
in the next version of the TNM staging system.
The findings of Poulos et al. contradict our study and of other authors
(1-4). The subject is controversial and demands further scrutiny. We
believe that macroscopic or microscopic involvement of the bladder neck
has different biologic implications. The original TNM classification
considered as T4 the macroscopic involvement of the bladder neck. Today
only microscopic involvement is seen on radical prostatectomies.
References
1. Yossepowitch O, Engelstein D, Konichezky M, Sella A, Livne PM, Baniel
J: Bladder neck involvement at radical prostatectomy: positive margins
or advanced T4 disese? Urology. 2000; 56: 448-52.
2. Dash A, Sanda MG: Prostate cancer involving the bladder neck: recurrence-free
survival and implications for AJCC staging modifications. Mod Pathol.
2002; 15: 159A.
3. Yossepowitch O, Sircar K, Scardino PT, Ohori M, Kattan MW, Wheeler
TM, et al.: Bladder neck involvement in pathological stage pT4 radical
prostatectomy specimens is not an independent prognostic factor. J Urol.
2002; 68: 2011-15.
4. Billis A, Freitas LLL, Magna LA: Prostate cancer with bladder neck
involvement: pathologic findings with application of a new practical method
for tumor extent evaluation and recurrence-free survival after radical
prostatectomy. Int Urol Nephrol. (in press).
Dr.
Athanase Billis
Full-Professor of Pathology
State University of Campinas, Unicamp
Campinas, São Paulo, Brazil
Prostate
needle biopsies: multiple variables are predictive of final tumor volume
in radical prostatectomy specimens
Poulos CK, Daggy JK, Cheng L
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Indiana University School
of Medicine, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA
Cancer. 2004; 101: 527-32
-
Background:
Tumor volume is one of the most powerful predictors of patient outcome
in prostatic adenocarcinoma. It is uncertain as to which preoperative
variables are most predictive of final tumor volume at radical prostatectomy,
especially among patients who have had positive biopsies at multiple
biopsy sites. The current study attempted to identify the biopsy variables
that are most predictive of final tumor volume.
-
Methods:
The authors examined prostate biopsy specimens from 151 consecutive
patients with at least 2 positive biopsy sites. The following data were
collected: highest percentage of adenocarcinoma at any biopsy site,
percentage of adenocarcinoma at the biopsy site with the highest Gleason
score, highest percentage of cores positive for adenocarcinoma at any
biopsy site, percentage of positive cores with carcinoma at the site
with the highest Gleason score, number of positive sites, tumor bilaterality,
and percentage of biopsy sites positive for disease. All patients underwent
radical prostatectomy. The prostatectomy specimens were entirely embedded
and whole mounted. Tumor volume was measured using the grid method.
Logarithmic transformation was applied to tumor volumes for the purposes
of the analysis.
-
Results:
Highest percentage of adenocarcinoma at any biopsy site (P = 0.012),
percentage of adenocarcinoma at the biopsy site with the highest Gleason
score (P = 0.021), number of positive biopsy sites (P = 0.026), tumor
bilaterality (P = 0.008), and percentage of biopsy sites positive for
disease (P = 0.0001) all were significant predictors of tumor volume
on linear regression analysis. Highest percentage of cores positive
for adenocarcinoma (P = 0.081) and percentage of positive cores with
carcinoma at the site with the highest Gleason score (P = 0.240) were
not significant predictors of tumor volume. Based on the model F statistic,
percentage of biopsy sites positive for tumor, tumor bilaterality, and
highest percentage of adenocarcinoma at any biopsy site were the variables
that were most predictive of tumor volume.
- Conclusions:
Highest percentage of adenocarcinoma at any biopsy site, percentage
of adenocarcinoma at the biopsy site with the highest Gleason score,
number of positive biopsy sites, tumor bilaterality, and percentage
of biopsy sites positive for disease all are useful preoperative predictors
of tumor volume in radical prostatectomy specimens. Although these preoperative
biopsy parameters were significant in linear regression models, none
was sufficient as a single predictor of tumor volume.
- Editorial
Comment
The study by Poulos et al. showed that multiple pathologic findings
seen in needle biopsies are predictive of final volume in radical prostatectomy
specimens. The authors used the grid method for measuring tumor volume.
Some institutions have calculated the tumor volume accurately, using
computer-assisted image analysis systems. Because this method is not
feasible for the routine clinical practice, other investigators have
proposed alternative simpler means. The grid method is one of these
alternative simpler means that measures tumor extent.
A number of studies have documented that the tumor extent, the volume
or the percentage of prostatic tissue involved by the tumor within the
prostate gland may be important prognostic indicators. However, the
subject is controversial. Although most authors agree that tumor extension
(percentage of carcinoma or tumor volume) in patients with prostate
carcinoma should be reported in radical prostatectomies because of its
prognostic importance, in some analyses, tumor size has not been considered
to be an independent predictor of tumor recurrence (1,2).
References
1. Esptein JI, Carmichael M, Partin AW, Walsh PC: Is tumor volume an independent
predictor of progression following radical prostatectomy? A multivariate
analysis of 185 clinical stage B adenocarcinoma of the prostate with 5
years of follow-up. J Urol. 1993; 149: 1478-85.
2. Billis A, Magna LA, Ferreira U: Correlation between tumor extent in
radical prostatectomies and preoperative PSA, histological grade, surgical
margins, and extraprostatic extension: application of a new practical
method for tumor extent evaluation. International Int Braz J Urol. 2003;
29: 113-20.
Dr.
Athanase Billis
Full-Professor of Pathology
State University of Campinas, Unicamp
Campinas, São Paulo, Brazil
INVESTIGATIVE
UROLOGY
Intracavernosal
injection of vascular endothelial growth factor improves erectile function
in aged rats
Park K, Ahn KY, Kim MK, Lee SE, Kang TW, Ryu SB
Department of Urology, Chonnam National University Medical School, Donggu,
Gwangju, Republic of Korea
Eur Urol. 2004; 46: 403-7
- Objectives:
To investigate whether intracavernosal injection of vascular endothelial
growth factor (VEGF) can restore erectile function in the aging rat.
-
Materials and Methods:
Ten young (4-5 months) and 30 old (24 months) Sprague-Dawley male rats
were used. The old rats were divided into 3 groups: vehicle-only (phosphate
buffered saline plus 0.1% bovine serum albumin; n = 10), VEGF 1 microg/kg
(n = 10), and VEGF 10 microg/kg (n = 10). At 2 and 4 weeks after treatment,
erectile function and histology were evaluated by hemodynamic study,
histomorphometric analysis, and immunohistochemistry.
-
Results: After
4 weeks of treatment, the ratio of peak intracavernosal pressure to
systemic arterial blood pressure in response to neurostimulation was
significantly higher in both the VEGF 1 microg/kg (79.9 +/- 7.7%) and
the VEGF 10 microg/kg group (76.8 +/- 5.8%) compared to the vehicle-only
group (63.1 +/- 8.5%; p < 0.05). The percentage of cavernosal smooth
muscle was significantly higher in the VEGF 10 microg/kg group (16.1
+/- 1.4%) compared to the vehicle-only group (12.8 +/- 2.2%; p = 0.047).
VEGF treatment in old rats increased e-NOS and VEGF expression in both
treatment groups.
-
Conclusion:
Intracavernosal injection of VEGF appears to restore smooth muscle integrity
and improve erectile function in aged rats.
- Editorial
Comment
This is an interesting and welcome study in the era of tissue engineering
techniques. After old rats treatment as described, the authors elegantly
evaluated through hemodynamic study, histomorphometric analysis and
immunohistochemistry, whether an intracavernosal injection of VEGF could
restore erectile function and whether it was related to trabecular structural
changes in aged rats.
The authors found that intracavernosal injection of VEGF resulted in
significant increases in intracavernous pressure in response to neurostimulation
after 4 weeks in both VEGF treatment groups. VEGF treatment in old rats
increased not only e-NOS and VEGF expression in endothelial lining,
but also the percentage of corpus cavernosal smooth muscle. Thus, intracavernosal
injection of VEGF improves penile erectile quality in aged rats.
Dr.
Francisco J.B. Sampaio
Full-Professor and Chair, Urogenital Research Unit
State University of Rio de Janeiro
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Fibrin glue for the suture-less correction of penile chordee:
a pilot study in a rabbit model
Hafez AT, El-Assmy A, El-Hamid MA
Urology & Nephrology Centre, Mansoura University, Mansoura, Egypt
BJU Int. 2004; 94: 433-6
-
Objective:
To evaluate the use of fibrin glue as a scaffold for patching defects
in the tunica albuginea in a rabbit model for a future application in
correcting chordee.
-
Materials and Methods:
Nine New Zealand white male rabbits were utilized. All had a 15 x 5-mm
defect created in the ventral tunica albuginea. Fibrin glue (1 mL) was
applied to cover the defect in tunica albuginea and the penile skin
closed with a continuous 5/0 chromic catgut suture. Animals were killed
in groups of three at 2, 6 and 12 weeks afterward. The evaluation included
an artificial erection test with intracavernosal injection of prostaglandin
E1 (5 microg), cavernosography and histopathological examination of
sections of the penis stained with haematoxylin and eosin or Masson
trichrome.
-
Results:
None of the rabbits died during the procedure or developed bleeding
or haematoma afterward. All animals had straight erections on testing
with prostaglandin (5 microg). There was no evidence of corporal narrowing
or venous leakage on cavernosography. Histopathological evaluation showed
evidence of the fibrin sealant layer, with angiogenesis and a cell infiltrate
at 2 weeks. At 6 and 12 weeks there was completely normal regeneration
of the tunica albuginea.
-
Conclusions:
In this pilot study in a rabbit model the haemostatic effect of fibrin
glue was confirmed on covering a defect in the tunica albuginea. Moreover,
there was regeneration of normal tunica albuginea with no scarring at
6 weeks and maintained at 12 weeks. Further well-controlled studies
are required before using fibrin glue for corporal body grafting to
treat chordee.
- Editorial
Comment
Many materials have been investigated for corporal body grafting in
surgical correction of chordee and Peyronie’s disease (porcine
small intestinal submucosa and tunica acellular matrix, as examples).
This article evaluated the feasibility of using a commercially available
fibrin glue (‘Tisseel’, Baxter Healthcare Corp., Irvine,
California) for covering corporal body defects, with potential application
in the surgical management of severe chordee. In rabbits, the results
were excellent. Fibrin glue may be considered a suitable substance for
corporal body grafting in the future.
Dr.
Francisco J.B. Sampaio
Full-Professor and Chair, Urogenital Research Unit
State University of Rio de Janeiro
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
RECONSTRUCTIVE
UROLOGY
Complete
primary repair of bladder exstrophy: initial experience with 33 cases
Hammouda HM, Kotb H
Urology (Pediatric Urology Division) Department, Assiut University, Assiut,
Egypt
J Urol. 2004; 172(4 Pt 1): 1441-4; discussion 1444
-
Purpose:
We evaluated our initial experience with complete primary repair of
bladder exstrophy in 33 children.
- Materials
and Methods: Between 1998 and 2001, 33 children with classic
bladder exstrophy were treated with 1-stage primary repair for the first
time in all except 4, who had undergone previous failed initial bladder
closure. Our series included 26 boys and 7 girls with a mean age of
2 months (range 3 weeks to 14 months). The bladder was closed in continuity
with the urethra and complete penile disassembly was used for epispadias
repair. Anterior transverse innominate osteotomy was performed in all
cases. Combined general and caudal anaesthesia were applied in all cases
with an indwelling epidural caudal catheter in 7.
-
Results:
Median followup was 42 months (range 24 to 62). Enterocystoplasty was
needed in 3 cases during primary repair of a small bladder plate. Wound
dehiscence was not recorded. Bladder neck fistula was reported in 2
children, while urethral fistula was recorded in 1 boy. Abdominal ultrasound
detected no hydronephrosis in all except 3 patients. Voiding cystourethrogram
showed vesicoureteral reflux in 6 patients. No loss of renal function
or febrile urinary tract infection was recorded. A dry interval of 3
hours or greater was reported in 24 children (72.7%), while 9 who were
incontinent of urine after failed toilet training needed other procedures
to achieve continence.
-
Conclusions:
Complete primary repair with penile disassembly provides a good approach
to achieve this purpose without the need for bladder neck reconstruction
in some cases. Selection of the proper surgical technique together with
adjunctive procedures such as osteotomy and a pain-free early postoperative
period can maximize the chance of successful exstrophy repair.
- Editorial
Comment
Reconstruction of the bladder, bladder neck and urethra in bladder exstrophy
patients is still a major challenge for a reconstructive urologist.
The series presented here with 33 children out of whom 29 underwent
a 1-stage primary repair for the first time is probably the largest
series to date. All operations were done in boys and girls less than
14 months old. Preoperative assessment was simple with an intravenous
pyelography or abdominal ultrasound. All surgical interventions were
done by the same pediatric urologist in all cases. Apart from a well
documented surgical technique, meticulous surgical handling was probably
the most important factor for having better results than in many other
series. There was a 76% continence rate in all children at a toilet
trained age. Only three patients - those that underwent enterocystoplasty
- were only continent on clean intermittent catheterization.
It is remarkable that incision of the muscular bladder wall is a possible
way to increase bladder capacity in those children where the bladder
template is too small. It is here that tissue engineering at some time
may become useful when earlier (maybe in utero) biopsy harvests may
be expanded in the laboratory to be used to increase the detrusor. The
bulging or expanding mucosa usually is not the problem especially not
in very young children.
Dr.
Arnulf Stenzl
Professor and Chairman of Urology
Eberhard-Karls-University Tuebingen
Tuebingen, Germany
Lymphadenectomy with cystectomy: is it necessary and what is its extent?
Ghoneim MA, Abol-Enein H
Urology & Nephrology Center, Gomhouria Street, Mansoura, Dakahlia
35516, Egypt
Eur Urol. 2004; 46: 457-461
- No
Abstract Available
- Editorial
Comment
Several decades ago, well known urologic surgeons in the field
made it clear that lymphadenectomy is an important part of anterior
exenteration. It was, however, thought to be useful only for staging.
More recent reports, however, both from the USA and Europe have shown
that patients with minimal involvement of lymph nodes and curable primary
transitional cell cancer of the bladder may survive even without further
adjuvant treatment. This means that nodal disease defined as N-1 in
the TNM system can be cured surgically, at least in some cases. In one
larger report the authors even found the T-stage to be more important
and the actual prognostic factor for survival regardless whether patients
were staged as N-0 or N-1 [1]. This prompted some authors to propose
an extension of pelvic lymphadenectomy cranially to the common iliac
and the para-aortic region.
The para-aortic and especially the common iliac region were the main
trunk of the sympathetic fibers supplying the hypogastric plexus could
be found. The division of these fibers may lead to functional problems
in the remnant urethra in patients undergoing an orthotopic neobladder
after cystectomy [2]. The present paper by two well-known experienced
surgeons is a well worked-up series of 200 patients undergoing radical
cystectomy and extended lymphadenectomy. Only two surgeons performed
all cystectomies, thereby reducing the possibility of an operator dependent
variation. The nodes from each anatomic region were sent on a separate
template for pathologic evaluation. It was demonstrated that none of
the patients with minimal lymph node disease-and those were the ones
that had a chance of cure-had nodal involvement outside the pelvic region.
They did find extrapelvic nodal disease, but in all cases these pN2
patients. Most of us agree with the authors’ conclusion that these
are not the patients which can be cured surgically.
For reconstructive purposes it is important that we can limit our lymphadenctomy
in certain patients to a level where we do not have to dissect the sympathetic
autonomic nerve supply to the hypogastric plexus and pelvic floor. Thereby
functional results of an orthotopic neobladder and vagina can be improved
without compromising oncological results.
References
1. Vieweg J, Gschwend JE, Herr HW, Fair WR: The impact of primary stage
on survival in patients with lymph node positive bladder cancer. J Urol.
1999; 161: 72-6.
2. Stenzl A, Colleselli K, Bartsch G: Update of urethra-sparing approaches
in cystectomy in women. World J Urol. 1997; 15: 134-8.
Dr.
Arnulf Stenzl
Professor and Chairman of Urology
Eberhard-Karls-University Tuebingen
Tuebingen, Germany
UROLOGICAL
ONCOLOGY
Post-brachytherapy
transurethral resection of the prostate in patients with localized prostate
cancer
Flam TA, Peyromaure M, Chauveinc L, Thiounn N, Firmin F, Cosset JM, Bernard
D.
Department of Urology, Hopital Cochin, Paris, France
J Urol. 2004; 172: 108-11
-
Purpose:
We assessed the rate and results of transurethral resection of the prostate
(TURP) in patients previously treated with brachytherapy as monotherapy
for localized prostate cancer.
- Materials
and Methods: From May 1998 to May 2003, 600 patients with localized
prostate cancer were treated with brachytherapy at our institution.
Brachytherapy was performed as monotherapy with curative intent for
clinically localized prostate cancer without adjuvant treatment in patients
with clinical stages T1c (68.4%) or T2a (31.6%) disease. -Iodine and
palladium implants were used in 583 and 7 patients, respectively. A
real-time interactive implantation technique was used in all but the
first 17 patients, who were treated using a preplanned technique.
-
Results:
Of the 600 patients 19 (3.1%) underwent TURP after brachytherapy. Among
the patients with acute urinary retention the median interval between
prostate brachytherapy and urinary retention was 2 months (range 0.5
to 32). No TURP was done within 6 months after implant. The median interval
between prostate brachytherapy and TURP was 7 months (range 6 to 41)
and median prostate specific antigen (PSA) before TURP was 0.5 ng/ml
(range 0.04 to 3.4). In the 19 patients the median weight of resected
prostatic tissue was 8 gm (range 2 to 19) and 1 to 11 seeds were removed
(median 5). The perioperative and postoperative courses were uneventful.
There was no TURP related incontinence. With a median followup of 28
months after brachytherapy (range 7 to 48) no patient had clinical or
biochemical evidence of disease progression, and for the group of 19
patients who underwent TURP median serum PSA at the end of followup
was 0.38 ng/ml (range 0.03 to 3.4).
-
Conclusions: After
brachytherapy as monotherapy, TURP can be done safely if indicated.
In our experience the resection of prostatic tissue along with a limited
number of seeds at least 6 months after implantation did not impair
PSA based biological and clinical results of brachy-therapy.
-
Editorial Comment
In rare instances TUR-P is necessary after brachytherapie for prostate
cancer. According to the literature there is a high risk of incontinence
in these patients. The authors addressed this point and stated that
there is no major risk of of TUR-P related incontinence after brachytherapy.
Even more interestingly, pathological examination of resected tissue
showed mostly fibrumuscular tissue with rare atrophic prostatic glands
and no evidence of cancer in all patients except for one, who had persistent
prostate cancer with gleason score of 8 on the TUR-P specimen 7 months
after brachytherapy, thus contradicting for brachytherapy previous notes
on external beam radiation that viable tumor tissue is detectable long-term
after irradiation.
Dr.
Andreas Böhle
Professor of Urology
HELIOS Agnes Karll Hospital
Bad Schwartau, Germany
Relationship between initial prostate specific antigen level and
subsequent prostate cancer detection in a longitudinal screening study
Antenor JA, Han M, Roehl KA, Nadler RB, Catalona WJ
Departments of Neurology, Washington University, School of Medicine, St.
Louis, Missouri, USA
J Urol. 2004; 172: 90-3
-
Purpose:
Previous studies of archived blood samples from nonscreened populations
have shown an association between the prostate specific antigen (PSA)
and the subsequent detection of prostate cancer. In the current study
we evaluated the relationship between the initial screening PSA and
the subsequent risk of prostate cancer detected in a prospective, longitudinal
screening study. We also examined the relationship between initial PSA
and the clinicopathological features of the cancers detected.
- Materials
and Methods: Between May 1991 and November 2001 we enrolled
26,111 volunteers in our PSA and digital rectal examination based prostate
cancer screening study. The men were followed biannually or annually
depending on the results of previous screening tests. The chi-square
and Kruskal-Wallis tests were used to compare the clinical stage, pathological
stage and Gleason score of subsequently detected prostate cancers as
well as the time to cancer detection in different initial screening
PSA strata.
-
Results:
The initial screening PSA stratum was strongly associated with the subsequent
detection of prostate cancer as well as the clinicopathological stage
and grade of the cancers detected.
-
Conclusions:
Even in the lower PSA ranges initial screening serum PSA can help identify
men at increased risk for subsequent prostate cancer detected in a longitudinal
screening study.
- Editorial
Comment
This paper is worthwhile reading for all urologists dealing with prostate
cancer.
In this screening study the risk of prostate cancer is estimated dependent
on the initial PSA value. Only 1% of men with initial PSA less than
1.0 ng/ml were subsequently diagnosed with prostate cancer. In contrast,
more than half of the men with initial PSA greater than 10 ng/ml were
subsequently diagnosed with cancer. 77% of those with initial PSA between
2.6 and 4.0 had organ confined disease while 67% with initial PSA between
4.0 and 10.0 had organ confined disease ( p=0.005 ) Of the men with
initial PSA between 2.6 and 4.0 ng/ml 42% eventually had PSA that increased
above 4.0 ng/ml, while only 2% of those with initial PSA less than 1.0
ng/ml had PSA that increased above 4.0 ng/ml during follow up.
The detailed tables show, that men with initial screening PSA between
2.0 and 3.0 had 14.9% relative risk of developing prostate cancer whereas
men with PSA 3.0 and 4.0 had relative risk of 23.3%.
All together these data support the notion, that close follow up of
men with initial PSA of at last higher than 2.5 should considered.
Dr.
Andreas Böhle
Professor of Urology
HELIOS Agnes Karll Hospital
Bad Schwartau, Germany
Biochemical failure as single abnormality in patients with prostate
cancer following radical treatment with external radiotherapy: follow-up
without immediate treatment
Faria SL, Salah M, David M, Souhami L, Duclos M, Shenouda G, Deblois F,
Janick C, Freeman CR
Department of Radio Oncology and Epidemiology of McGill University, Montreal
General Hospital, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Int Braz J Urol. 2004; 30: 289-95
-
Introduction:
Biochemical failure has been defined as 3 consecutive increases in PSA
following curative treatment of prostate cancer. The appropriate management
in such cases is controversial. The most usual treatment has been early
introduction of hormones. Such patients will live for many years and
hormone therapy causes important secondary effects and increases costs.
The guideline in our Department of Radiotherapy has been to follow up,
with no initial therapy, cases with low PSA and short PSA doubling time.
The present study reports this experience.
-
Materials and Methods:
528 patients with localized prostate cancer were treated by radical
approach between 1992 and 1999, with external radiotherapy, with or
without adjuvant hormone therapy. After a median follow-up of 77 months,
there were 207 (39%) cases with biochemical failure, 78 of which were
followed without therapy after the identification of biochemical failure.
All of them were asymptomatic patients and had negative radiographic
examinations or did not have imaging exams requested since they presented
a favorable outcome. The follow-up included at least 2 annual visits
with physical examination and PSA.
-
Results:
Of the 78 patients with biochemical failure followed without initial
therapy, 7 died from other causes than prostate cancer and the remaining
71 cases were alive and asymptomatic in the last follow-up. Prognostic
factors previous to radiotherapy such as stage and Gleason score were
not considered when deciding for follow-up without initial therapy in
these cases. The most significant aspects considered for this decision
were low PSA value (median PSA on the last visit for the 78 cases was
only 3.9 ng/mL) and a slow PSA doubling time (in the present experience
the median PSA doubling time was 22.5 months).
-
Conclusion:
There seems to be space for expectant management, without initial hormone
therapy, in patients with prostate cancer who present biochemical failure
and are asymptomatic after radical external radiotherapy. This decision
is important, since early introduction of hormones brings late effects
and is expensive. Prospective and randomized studies are required to
define this issue.
- Editorial
Comment
The issue of treatment for rising PSA after definitive therapy, either
by external beam radiation therapy, the subject in this report, or by
radical prostatectomy remains a critical dilemma in the management of
patients with prostate cancer. It is critical because of the frequency
of occurrence (in this report 39% of 528 patients), the lack of evidence-based
medicine upon which to ground one’s decision, and the apprehension
that is associated with serial PSA monitoring. As this report indicates,
the therapy is often prompted by a “chicken switch” reaction.
Until data is available, and it is unlikely that it will be in the foreseeable
future, careful evaluation of prognostic variables as the authors describe,
provide the therapist with at least a logical approach to triggering
the switch to androgen deprivation. Pretreatment of Gleason score and
PSA and post-treatment progression indicators as PSA level and doubling
time currently provide the trigger for the delivery of androgen deprivation
to those for whom it will benefit most and withhold it from those who
are at sufficiently low risk that the morbidity consequence to the therapy
equals or outweighs the benefits that androgen therapy could deliver.
Clinical trials will provide the most useful and unbiased information.
Some of the current Phase III trials addressing the issue of PSA recurrence
are continuous vs intermittent androgen deprivation after irradiation
(JPR7 – NCI, Canada); androgen deprivation and immediate vs delayed
chemotherapy (RTOG, P0014), androgen deprivation ± thalidomide
(NCI-00-C0080) and for patients with a rising PSA after androgen deprivation
but without evidence of metastatic disease, a trial comparing second
line hormone therapy (ketoconazol + hydrocortisone) to chemotherapy
(docetaxel and estramustine – ECOG 1899).
Other agents are being investigated to address the rising PSA; i.e.
Provenge, Atrasantin (endothelin-A inhibitor), Avastin (angrogenesis
inhibitor).
Dr.
Paul F. Schellhammer
Program Director of the Virginia Prostate Center
Professor of Urology, Eastern Virginia Medical School
Norfolk, Virginia USA
FEMALE
UROLOGY
Percutaneous
tibial nerve stimulation in the treatment of overactive bladder: urodynamic
data
Vandoninck V, van Balken MR, Agrò EF, Petta F, Micali F, Heesakkers
JPFA, Debruyne FMJ, Kiemeney LALM, Bemelmans BLH
Department of Urology, University Medical Center Nijmegen, PO Box 9101,
NL-6500 HB Nijmegen, The Netherlands
Neurourol Urodyn. 2004; 23: 246-51
-
Aim:
The aim of this study was to evaluate urodynamic changes after percutaneous
tibial nerve stimulation (PTNS) for the treatment of complaints related
to overactive bladder syndrome and to search for urodynamic-based predictive
factors.
-
Methods: Ninety
consecutive patients with symptoms related to overactive bladder syndrome
were enrolled in this study. Patients underwent 12 PTNS sessions. For
evaluating objective success, the primary outcome measure was a reduction
in number of urinary leakage episodes of 50% or more per 24 hours. Patients’
request for continuation of therapy was considered subjective success.
This study focused on urodynamic features at baseline and on changes
found after 12 PTNS treatments.
-
Results:
The objective success rate was 56% (leakages/24 hours). Subjective success
rate was 64%. Frequency/volume chart data and quality of life scores
improved significantly (P < 0.01). Pre- and posturodynamic data were
available from 46 participants. Detrusor instabilities (DI) could be
abolished in a few cases only. Increments in cystometric bladder capacity
and in volume at DI were significant (P = 0.043 and 0.012, respectively).
Subjects without detrusor instabilities at baseline were 1.7 times more
prone to respond to PTNS (odds ratio, 1.75; 95% confidence interval
[CI], 0.67-4.6). The more the bladder overactivity was pronounced, the
less these patients were found to respond to PTNS, the area under the
receiver operating curve was 0.644 (95% CI, 0.48-0.804).
-
Conclusion:
PTNS could not abolish DI. PTNS increased cystometric capacity and delayed
the onset of DI. Cystometry seemed useful to select good candidates:
patients without DI or with late DI onset proved to be the best candidates
for PTNS.
- Editorial
Comment
The authors studied 90 patients with symptoms of OAB and performed 12
percutaneous tibial nerve stimulation (PTNS) on them. Their goal in
obtaining objective success was a diminution of urinary leaking episodes
by 50% or more per 24 hours. When available, the authors examined urodynamic
features at baseline and after the course of therapy were completed.
They found that patients without any evidence of detrusor overactivity
had a 1.7 times more chance of responding to this therapy than patients
with detrusor overactivity. In addition, the more pronounced the detrusor
activity, the less chance of success would be obtained through this
modality.
Sacral nerve stimulation has now established itself as an option of
therapy in patients with severe OAB, especially those who have failed
pharmacologic therapy. Some urologists are somewhat reticent to become
involved in sacral nerve stimulation secondary to the methods of preliminary
testing or application of the technology. Into this niche, there may
a position for PTNS. Percutaneous tibial nerve stimulation should be
reviewed by all urologists for a potential addition for an office therapy,
especially if they treat a significant number of patients with voiding
dysfunction secondary to detrusor overactivity. The great value of this
paper is both as an introduction to percutaneous nerve stimulation as
well as helping to identify the sub-populations of patients with voiding
dysfunction who this therapy may assist. Long term questions to be answered
include its success in the different populations of male vs. female,
detrusor activity and voiding dysfunction as well as the durability
of the therapy after the multi week course of therapy has been completed.
I advise all physicians who are interested in developing or introducing
nerve stimulation in their practice to read this article and consider
trying this therapy.
Dr.
Steven P. Petrou
Associate Professor of Urology
Mayo Clinic College of Medicine
Jacksonville, Florida, USA
Delayed treatment of bladder outlet obstruction after sling surgery:
association with irreversible bladder dysfunction
Leng WW, Davies BJ, Tarin T, Sweeney DD, Chancellor MB
Department of Urology, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania,
USA
J Urol. 2004; 172(Part 1 of 2): 1379-81
-
Purpose: Our
urethrolysis cohort demonstrated an unusual delay time to surgical treatment
of bladder outlet obstruction. We determined whether urethrolysis outcomes,
i.e. persistent bladder symptoms, were associated with time between
sling and urethrolysis surgeries.
-
Materials and Methods:
Retrospective analysis of all patients who underwent urethrolysis for
post-sling voiding dysfunction between June 1997 and June 2002 was performed.
We excluded from study 6 patients with a known history of overactive
bladder symptoms, neurogenic bladder dysfunction and use of anticholinergic
pharmacotherapy before stress incontinence surgery. The remaining 15
patients were stratified into 2 outcomes groups based upon the absence
or presence of post-urethrolysis bladder storage symptoms. Patients
(7) in group 1 have no current bladder symptoms. Patients (8) in group
2 still require anticholinergic drug therapy for significant bladder
symptoms of frequency and urgency. Data collected for the 2 groups included
mean age, existence of urinary retention before urethrolysis, mean time
to urethrolysis in months, urethrolysis outcome based upon subjective
bladder symptoms and followup duration. For comparison of mean age between
groups, the standard t test was used. Fisher’s exact test was
used to compare frequency of urinary retention before urethrolysis between
groups. Lastly, the Mann-Whitney U test was conducted to compare time
to urethrolysis between groups. All statistical analyses were conducted
using the SPSS software package (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, Illinois).
-
Results:
There was no statistically significant difference between the groups
with respect to age or frequency of urinary retention before urethrolysis.
Time to urethrolysis for the whole cohort ranged from 2 to 66 months.
Mean followup after urethrolysis was 17.3 +/- 22.9 months. Comparison
of mean time between incontinence and urethrolysis surgeries between
group 1 (9.0 +/- 10.1 months) and group 2 (31.25 +/- 21.9 months) demonstrated
a statistically significant difference (p = 0.01).
-
Conclusions:
This urethrolysis population demonstrated an unusual delay time to surgical
treatment of bladder outlet obstruction. We categorized the cohort according
to absence or presence of persistent bladder storage symptoms, and found
a strong association between persistent bladder symptoms and greater
delay to urethrolysis.
- Editorial
Comment
The authors review their specific population of urethrolysis patients
and retrospectively analyze the response to surgery and its relation
to the passage of time between the original sling and the subsequent
urethrolysis. The analysis revealed a strong association between persistent
bladder symptoms and greater delay to urethrolysis.
This paper is very timely in view that it raises the issue of when should
one intercede for relief of obstruction secondary to an outlet procedure.
The paper may have a had a greater degree of illumination had there
been more definition of the urinary symptoms preoperatively and postoperatively.
During the review of the paper, one may infer that the authors assume
that all their urethrolysis patients were surgically successful and
that the continuation of symptoms was basically due to anatomic/physiologic
changes associated with obstruction as opposed to technique failure.
Nevertheless, the take home message from this paper is that as soon
as the diagnosis of infravesical outlet obstruction is diagnosed it
should be definitively remedied; this may be valuable advice indeed
when deciding when to intercede with this specific subset of patients.
Dr.
Steven P. Petrou
Associate Professor of Urology
Mayo Clinic College of Medicine
Jacksonville, Florida, USA
PEDIATRIC
UROLOGY
The
ambitions of adolescents born with exstrophy: a structured survey
Wilson C, Christie D, Woodhouse CR
Department of Child and Adolescent Psychological Services, University
College London and Middlesex Hospitals, London, UK
BJU Int. 2004; 94: 607-12
-
Objective:
To determine the factors that control quality of life as perceived by
adolescent patients with bladder exstrophy, and to compare their views
using standard instruments.
-
Patients and Methods:
Sixteen patients (mean age 19 years, range 16-21, 11 male and five female)
were recruited from the departmental database; they represented 46%
of those available for the study. After giving informed consent, each
had a semi-structured interview, augmented by completing a self-reported
scale, with the principal investigator. They then completed the Culture-Free
Self-Esteem Inventory-2 (CFSEI-2) and the Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI).
The interviews were recorded on audiocassette, transcribed verbatim
and evaluated using interpretative phenomenological analysis.
-
Results: In
the interviews there was a remarkable consistency in the domains identified
as important to the patients. There was a wish to be normal and to be
treated as such. This was defined (amongst other items) as being able
to void with an appropriate noise, being treated as peers at school
and at home, and having an umbilicus. All patients reported some bullying
(all but one in the past), but only severely in three. Concerns about
self-image centred on scars and genital appearance. Very similar and
effective coping strategies had been created, including practical (e.g.
suitable clothes) and emotional (e.g. joking, control of revealed information)
aspects. Special arrangements made to help (care by a special assistant
or use of a disabled lavatory at school) served only to emphasize their
abnormality and were resented. No overt psychiatric or psychological
morbidity was detected. There was no difference in scores with the CFSEI-2
or BSI from established age-related norms.
-
Conclusion:
This study confirms the anecdotally reported strong resilience and personality
of adolescents with exstrophy. The domains that patients considered
important were not those that their carers might have expected or that
are used in standard quality-of-life instruments. No morbidity was identified
by the two instruments used. In exstrophy, and perhaps in other uncommon
conditions, the patients’ views of relevant domains should be
considered in assessing quality of life.
- Editorial
Comment
There have been increasing concerns about the psychosocial health of
adolescents and young adults born with severe congenital anomalies,
like bladder exstrophy. There are few accurate quality of life instruments
applicable to these conditions and most are not disease-specific. What
data are available are via anecdote or interview and are subject to
personal bias.
It is with this as a basis that this paper is of great value. Sixteen
patients were evaluated (admittedly only 46% of the sample) via a number
of different instruments. It is not surprising that there was an overwhelming
wish to “be normal”. Among the disease specific concerns
was the desire to “sound” normal while emptying their bladders!
Interestingly many resented support structures meant to make their lives
easier, if these methods singled them out as being different. Body image
was quite important as would be anticipated. This was especially so
with regards to genitalia in boys and surprisingly to the umbilicus.
The lack of an umbilicus drew attention to their being different and
affected clothing choices! Overall, these patients appeared to be hard-working,
non-complaining and very resilient. They seemed quite adept at developing
coping strategies and related well to adults.
Overall the authors are to be congratulated on a very strong effort
at focusing on specific quality of life issues that affect these children.
This should make a large difference to clinicians caring for these patients
in the future. This type of work would be of great benefit to patients
with other diseases that we care for and should be encouraged.
Dr.
Barry A. Kogan
Chief and Professor of Urology and Pediatrics
Albany Medical College
Albany, New York, USA
The physical characteristics of young males with varicocele
Delaney DP, Carr MC, Kolon TF, Snyder HM 3rd, Zderic SA
Division of Urology, The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania , USA
BJU Int. 2004; 94: 624-6
-
Objective:
To determine if there is an association with habitus in young males
with varicocele, as adolescent boys with varicoceles appear to be mostly
taller and leaner than age-matched controls.
-
Patients and Methods:
Retrospectively reviewing our records we obtained the height and weight
of 43 consecutive males (mean age 14.3 years, range 11-19) under long-term
follow-up for varicocele. The body mass index (BMI), heights and weights
were compared with values from the respective growth charts for boys
aged 2-20 years (Center for Disease Control and Prevention), and the
statistical significance of differences determined using the chi-square
test.
- Results:
The height and weight distributions of patients with varicocele
indicated a significant deviation from normal in the 25-95th percentiles
for stature and in the 25-75th for weight (P < 0.05). Deviations
in BMI were insignificantly different from normal at each percentile.
-
Conclusion:
These results indicate that patients with varicocele are significantly
taller and heavier than age-matched controls. Future studies to address
the key areas identified in this study will help to further assess the
distribution of the incidence of varicocele in closely defined subsets
of adolescent growth and development, which may provide some insight
into the cause of varicoceles.
- Editorial
Comment
The relationship between body habitus and varicocele has been a matter
of conjecture. Anecdotal data suggest that patients with varicoceles
are tall and thin. However, this has never previously been investigated.
The authors in this study compare the heights, weights and body mass
index of varicocele patients to national norms. They discovered that
indeed, their varicocele patients were taller than average. They also
found that their patients were heavier than normal, but that their body
mass index was only slightly increased.
This interesting observation leads to further conjecture about the cause
of the adolescent varicocele. Why are these patients more likely to
be tall? Conversely, are tall patients more likely to have varicoceles
and if so, why? Does this have to do with the length of the spermatic
vein? Does it have to do with posture or athleticism? Similarly, why
are they heavier, but with a relatively normal body mass index? Is their
weight increased due to muscle mass as opposed to adipose tissue? This
nice descriptive study leaves more questions than it answers, but opens
the door to future investigations. One wonders what other diseases might
occur in patients with specific body habitus.
Dr.
Barry A. Kogan
Chief and Professor of Urology and Pediatrics
Albany Medical College
Albany, New York, USA |